I think this is a good comparison. I was although thinking about this in relation to Justin Morneau the other day. When Morneau came up, he was embarrassing at first base, especially compared to the guy he replaced (which, fortunately for Trevor Plouffe, is not a problem Plouffe faces). Although Morneau certainly isn't Doug Mientkiewicz, because Doug Mientkiewicz was by a country mile the best defender at first base that I've seen in my lifetime, Morneau plays All Star caliber first base every day as a matter of course. One thing Morneau, Koskie, and Plouffe have in common is that they were not born with the body types to make them naturally gifted infielders. Morneau and Koskie got where they did as defenders because they worked hard, and Plouffe's a guy that looks like he works hard. Is Plouffe ever going to be a Gold Glove candidate at third? Probably not. But although fair criticisms can be made, he's far from embarrassing at the hot corner, and in my opinion, has made no more or fewer boneheaded plays in the last month than anyone else in the infield not named Justin Morneau. Frankly, I'm much more aggravated with Florimon, who does have the natural tools and defensive reputation and hasn't made a very good showing early on, either in terms of quick thinking or consistent effort. (You're not paying your own laundry bill, kid, lay out.) I think if Plouffe was hitting even marginally more consistently we wouldn't even be discussing this. Gardenhire jerking him around like this all the time isn't helping anybody either. Just sayin'.