Jump to content
Twins Daily
  • Create Account
  • You're Wrong About Brian Dozier, And So Is MLB

    Ted Schwerzler

    A reminder: You can still vote for Brian Dozier in the Final Vote until 3:00 this afternoon. From 9-3 central time, you can also do the #VoteDozier thing on Twitter, and you'll even get to see the little Dozier emoji. Get out the vote! #VoteDozier all day!

    Just under a month ago, I told you that Brian Dozier was entering elite territory in major league baseball. Since that time, Dozier has done nothing but squash my silly notion. Instead of entering elite territory, he instead has defined what elite is. At this point, you're probably wrong about the Twins second basemen, and so is MLB itself.

    Image courtesy of Brad Rempel USATODAY- Sports

    We are less than a week away from the midsummer classic. Major League Baseball has unfortunately pinned World Series implications on the exhibition, and while many players still overlook that implication, the fact is that this does count. The process in place often leads to fans voting for the biggest names or their favorite jerseys. This process will often not draw wonderful reviews, and it's probably time Major League Baseball is held accountable.

    As the fan voting took place for the All-Star Game in Cincinnati this year, we watched as the Royals fans came out of the woodwork and make a mockery of the system. Even the Kauffman faithful had to find humor in the fact that their .231/.240/.307 slashing second basemen was pacing a portion of the voting. While it isn't unexpected to have snubs on the fans' part, it's pretty ugly that manager Ned Yost failed to get it right as well.

    Last season, the Minnesota Twins watched Brian Dozier blossom before their eyes. Going from a relative unknown to one of the most surprising power-hitters in the game, Dozier received some national attention in the home run derby. While it was the consolation prize for nor receiving an All-Star appearance he was more than qualified for, it was a stepping stone.

    After being among the best in the big leagues in runs scored, and securing a shiny new 4-year, $20 million contract, how would Dozier respond? The answer is by continuing to be the best second basemen in baseball and it's not particularly close. Dozier's 7.6 WAR since the beginning of 2014 ranks above all other qualifiers, and Houston's Jose Altuve is next closest with a 6.7 mark.

    On the season, Dozier leads the big leagues in runs scored (63) and is on pace for career highs in doubles, triples, hits, home runs, runs batted in, batting average and OPS. In fact, it's actually that last number that might be most impressive when looking at the Twins second basemen.

    Often times, detractors will point to Dozier's average as a reason why he shouldn't be regarded among the game's best. Despite his .245 career mark (.260 in 2015), Brian Dozier's value at the plate goes far beyond that of other second basemen.

    With an .849 OPS, the Twins second basemen lays claim to the 15th best mark in all of baseball. Of those 14 players ahead of him, the only ones not to be named All-Stars: Alex Rodriguez (.902) and Brett Gardner (.854, also in the final vote). When adjusting for ballparks with OPS+, Dozier falls just one spot to 16th. Players behind Dozier in OPS include Jose Abreu, Dustin Pedroia, and Adam Jones.

    Bringing it back full circle to the context of the All-Star Game, Dozier looks poised to be snubbed yet again in the Final Vote. Once again placing the onus on the fans, Dozier goes up against Xander Bogaerts, Yoenis Cespedes, Brett Gardener and Mike Moustakas. If the initial vote was any indication as to how this Final Vote might go, the Royals' Moustakas appears to have the edge.

    Looking at Moustakas, the biggest Dozier detractors are forced to come full circle. After scuffling through the first four seasons of his career, Moustakas has put it together for Kansas City. He's got seven home runs, 31 RBI and is slashing .301/.357/.436. That last bit of information is the most important however.

    Despite hitting .41 points higher than Dozier, Moustakas owns an OPS (.793) a stout .56 points lower.

    It probably can't be made any clearer: Brian Dozier hitting for average absolutely, positively, does not matter. As long as he is getting on base and generating extra base hits, the Twins second basemen will remain the best in baseball.

    At the end of the day, or maybe better said, at the end of the first half of the MLB season, Brian Dozier was failed. He may not care on the surface whether or not he was included in a meaningless* exhibition, but the fans failing to acknowledge him failed, Ned Yost failed, and Major League Baseball failed.

    All-Star Game aside, Brian Dozier continues to come to work and get the job done. It's probably the best interests of all of us to take notice sooner rather than later. Until then, he'll keep hitting walk-off shots and flipping his doubters the...bat.

    For more from Off The Baggy, click here. Follow @tlschwerz


    Featured Video

    User Feedback

    Recommended Comments

    Featured Comments

    I'm a big Dozier believer, but many of the points you used to champion Dozier, particularly in regards to whether he should be in the All-Star game, would point to Dozier not being the best second baseman in the league.  For this year, that man is Jason Kipnis.


    WAR--Kipnis is out performing Dozier by 50%, with a 4.8 WAR to Dozier's 3.2.


    OPS--Kipnis is far clear of Dozier, as he is OPS'ing .904 to Dozier's .843


    Kipnis is also walking more than Dozier, striking out less, batting 70 points higher, OBP'ing nearly 80 points higher, and within 20 points of slugging.  He's also, according to fangraphs, been better than Dozier on the basepaths, and in the field as well.


    Dozier should definitely have gotten into the game above Altuve, but unfortunately, Altuve is who the fans voted in.

    Link to comment
    Share on other sites

    My thumbs hurt from voting.....all for naught. I didn't think I'd be as disappointed as I am about it. As evidenced by some of the extremely well written articles on this site, Brian Dozier is a more than deserving All Star player

    Link to comment
    Share on other sites

    Please, please pardon mte French, but what an effing travesty to even have a royal in the 'final five', after the BS all star vote. Who decided that? Who is responsible? What bull****. To F a guy like Dozier out of a well- deserved spot, for a guy who's not even in the top 10 of many of hos positional categories...Fk .

    Link to comment
    Share on other sites

    Join the conversation

    You can post now and register later. If you have an account, sign in now to post with your account.
    Note: Your post will require moderator approval before it will be visible.

    Add a comment...

    ×   Pasted as rich text.   Paste as plain text instead

      Only 75 emoji are allowed.

    ×   Your link has been automatically embedded.   Display as a link instead

    ×   Your previous content has been restored.   Clear editor

    ×   You cannot paste images directly. Upload or insert images from URL.


  • Create New...