Jump to content
Twins Daily
  • Create Account

Is Nelson Cruz Cooked?

Ted Schwerzler



Twins Video

Over the winter the Minnesota Twins and Nelson Cruz looked at each fondly while they also had discussions from a distance. Although it seemed destined that a reunion would happen, the pieces had to fall into place. Now, through 47 games in 2021, maybe the victor of all the spoils is finally going to be Father Time.


Coming off a season in which Cruz played in 53 games for the Twins, Minnesota watched him follow up a 1.031 OPS in 2019 with a .992 mark. Although Rocco Baldelli’s club wasn’t a complete reincarnation of the Bomba Squad, Cruz continued to send the ball over the fence with routine frequency. That is still happening in 2021 as he’s on pace to smash 30 homers, but that would also be his lowest total since 2013.


Then there’s what happened in May. Sure, Cruz’s .839 OPS is still fine, especially for a man doing this at 40 years old. That said, he posted a lackluster .663 OPS in the month of May, launched just three dingers, and owned a 23/9 K/BB. His 33.9% hard hit rate on the year is the lowest it’s been since 2011, and his 18.9% HR/FB rate is something he’s virtually never messed with.


When Cruz started in the big leagues way back in 2007, the average fastball velocity he faced was 91.5 mph. Now, that’s been ratcheted up to 94 mph and combined with an aging human body. He’s also made things harder on himself by posting a career worst 34.8% chase rate.


At some point this was all bound to happen. 2020 caused concern for me down the stretch as well. Over the final month Cruz owned just an .844 OPS, which wouldn’t be as negative if he weren’t dropping off from a 1.068 mark to that point. He then completely hit the skids over the final 11 games of the season, owning just a .523 OPS with two extra-base hits. It is true that Cruz was one of the only Twins to contribute during the Postseason, but that was a three-game sample that amounted to just six total at bats.


Maybe the month of May was a grind for Cruz, and maybe he’s still coming out of some lingering effects following the hit by pitch. What would certainly not be a good development for a bad Twins team is that their slugger is falling off a cliff, and it’s a reality that would hurt twice as much when it comes to the deadline and any opportunity to flip him for assets becomes more of a chore than a choice.


We’ve seen Cruz stave of the aging process for quite some time. If the Twins are going to come back in 2021, or get anything back for their designated hitter, we’ll need one last encore.


For more from Off The Baggy, click here. Follow @tlschwerz



Recommended Comments

He doesn't look cooked to me, but he has some interesting splits.  In 2021 so far, he played better when the Twins lost.  The Twins have lost just a little more than they have won, so overall he is doing well.  

Yes, he is down in May, but

  1. Who the heck wouldn't be down in May on this team?
  2. It's not like the bottom fell out and he's hitting like he is in one of Sano's dry spells or something.  He is still producing.  He had just as many multi-hit games in May as he had in April.

Cruz's May looks like a standard, uninteresting slump.  Let me know if it lasts another six weeks.

Link to comment

His Ground ball rate has risen quite a bit in May, over 49%.  His career is 41.7%.  His line drive rate seems to be what took the hit as it dropped to 7% in May down from his usual 20-22% he has been having with the Twins.


I believe it is the wrist more than old age.  His exit velocity and hard hit% were not off his career marks by this much for the first month.


Injuries are way up this year, probably to be expected with the short season last year.  League wide offense is also way down this year.  I don't think he would fall off this much from old age in so short of a time.


If you add up all the offense for all of MLB, the stat line is .236/.312/.393.  I don't think anyone would consider that when talking about the average MLB player.

Link to comment
44 minutes ago, 4twinsJA said:

Don't think he is cooked, but definitely last year as Twin. Hopefully recent performance due to wrist injury.

The biggest worry I have regarding the wrist, is that happened near the end of May. He was struggling prior to that happening.

Link to comment
Add a comment...

×   Pasted as rich text.   Paste as plain text instead

  Only 75 emoji are allowed.

×   Your link has been automatically embedded.   Display as a link instead

×   Your previous content has been restored.   Clear editor

×   You cannot paste images directly. Upload or insert images from URL.

  • Create New...