Jump to content
Twins Daily
  • Create Account
  • entries
  • comments
  • views

Good reasons why Red-Cross Rocco should be let go




Twins Video

By David Weinshilboum


In 2013, the Golden State Warriors basketball team seemed on the verge. A franchise that had been a laughingstock for decades had been to the playoffs two years in a row. Led by coach Mark Jackson and a young injury-prone sharpshooter by the name of Stephen Curry, the steam had suddenly thrust itself into relevancy.


Yet, just three days after a playoff loss in 2013, the Warriors fired Jackson (who had a year left on his contract). He was a good coach who had many positive attributes. The team was headed in the right direction. Why fire him?


The Warriors hired Steve Kerr who implemented a new offense that maximized Curry’s long-range shooting abilities. The team went on to win Championships in three of the next four seasons. As the tired sports cliché goes, the rest is history.

The Minnesota Twins – until this train-wreck of a year—were a team and organization on the rise. Then rookie manager Rocco Baldelli led the Twins to a 100-win season in 2019 and another division championship in the pandemic-shortened 2020 season.


Today the Twins are mired in a disaster season that simply isn’t going to get better. Their best player is injured and half a dozen others are playing well below expectations (Sano, Maeda, Kepler, Polanco and, sorry to put this in print, Colome). When the Twins 2021 season comes to a close, they will be a failure: no playoffs and well below expectations of 90-plus wins.


In October, the Twins will have to ask themselves an important question: is Baldelli the leader who can take this team and franchise to the next level? I would argue that, for some very rational, logical reasons, the answer is no.


The Twins Twitterverse wants Rocco’s head now, and a few days ago, during a television broadcast, a fan wandered behind home plate and held a sign calling for a managerial change. There’s a lot of emotion going into the Fire Rocco movement. Baldelli has NEVER been a good in-game manager, oftentimes making fans scratch their heads or, at times, yank tufts of hair from scalp. His choice of defensive substitutions, pinch hitters and pinch runners feels arbitrary at best. The most obvious example was a couple weeks ago in Oakland when, in extra innings, Baldelli pinch ran Travis Blankenhorn for Josh Donaldson. The move compromised defense in a big way. And Baldelli made matters worse when he put second-baseman Luis Arraez at third and Blankenhorn at second – eroding the leather at TWO positions instead of just one. The game ended when Blankenhorn booted one grounder and Arraez air-mailed a routine throw to first.


Another reason fans might dislike him is his press conference demeanor: he is dullard diplomat who makes former Vikings Coach/statue Bud Grant look emotional. Worse, he never calls out terrible plays – both physical or mental – and seems to dismiss garbage baseball as “part of the game.”


Neither of these negative attributes are fireable offenses, though.


Baldelli is a good manager. Players love him. They want to play for him. He is flexible and allows them to select preparation that fits their needs. He maximized player abilities in 2019, getting the most out of Miguel Sano, Mitch Garver and Max Kepler.


All good things must come to an end, though. And Baldelli’s millennial approach to players might not be as conducive to good baseball as it once was. This year, many players aren’t properly prepared for games. Too often, players seem to be using their first at-bat to “learn” about a pitcher’s repertoire instead of reviewing the scouting reports. Players appear ok with early-inning strikeouts since they’ve seen the stuff. It’s not a stretch to assume many Twins are taking advantage of Rocco’s laissez faire approach to being game ready.


Also, Rocco’s concern for injured players seems incredibly detrimental to the team, particularly given how the roster has been assembled. The Front Office has routinely preferred more pitchers and a short bench. But Red-Cross Rocco sits players if they report a hangnail. Worse, he won’t even consider them for pinch hitting or late-inning defense. There have been over a dozen instances this season when Baldelli has chosen to pinch hit a weaker bat instead of a resting star who is at 90 percent. All for the sake of future health. In a year where rosters are 26 players deep, the Twins have been playing with 22 or 23 players.


Is Baldelli having a bad year? Absolutely. When the leader of the team forgets how many mound visits have been made, it’s a bad, bad look. The Twins in many ways have played the way Baldelli has managed this year: haphazardly, unevenly and obliviously. Baldelli certainly has the ability to manage better than he has. But when his contract ends, the Twins must decide whether he is the best fit for the club. Their decision will be huge because this team is on the precipice of irrelevancy.


David Weinshilboum lives in California and bemoans this year’s Twins ineptitude from afar. Follow @weinshie on Twitter.



Recommended Comments

When there's a fire going on, most people wouldn't wait until the season is over to put it out.


Rocco has had the benefit in the past from having a competent bench coach next to him. But this year with no bench coach (RIP Mike Bell & losing Derek Shelton to the Pirates) has exposed Rocco even more as a bad in-game manager.

Link to comment

You all know the front office is not going to send Rocco walking (yet). They will give him every opportunity to pull the troops together and bring respect back to the team.  What are the odds of that happening?  The team will likely consider itself successful to pull back near 500.  (At least we won't have to suffer through the annual 3 postgame losses.)  

The club is on the verge of another "total system failure."  FO, Mgr and players are all having sub-par years.  If I ran the club I'd hire the best sports psychologist available.  There are too many players with ping pong balls dancing between their ears right now.  Is this something a manager can fix?  

Hold on Twins fans.  You will have to put your WS championship hopes on hold once again.  It's been 30 years....you can wait a bit longer.

(PS  If/when Bux gets back at least there will be something worth watching.)



Link to comment

You've certainly created a narrative here, but it's lacking evidence, in my opinion.

For example, you claim:


This year, many players aren’t properly prepared for games. Too often, players seem to be using their first at-bat to “learn” about a pitcher’s repertoire instead of reviewing the scouting reports. Players appear ok with early-inning strikeouts since they’ve seen the stuff. It’s not a stretch to assume many Twins are taking advantage of Rocco’s laissez faire approach to being game ready.

This claim does not align with reality, as the Twins have had one of the best offenses in baseball in innings 1-3 so far this season (#2 in MLB in wRC+, #3 in OPS). It's the late innings that have been their downfall.

I also don't see any evidence for your claim that "Rocco’s concern for injured players seems incredibly detrimental to the team." He and his staff seem to be managing injuries in a similar manner as they did over the past two seasons when they won division titles and had one of the best records in baseball. If anything, he has shown more willingness this season to bring guys back from injury more quickly (see Miguel Sanó's return from his recent IL stint) or have them play through injuries (it was reported that Buxton was playing through several nagging injuries before he was put on the IL with his hip flexor strain). I think his managing style this season has reflected the fact that the situation is more desperate and the team doesn't have the luxury of making sure everyone is 100% healthy when they play.

I believe there are plenty of legitimate reasons to criticize Baldelli this year, but I don't think they'd be in a much different situation with a different manager at the helm. In general, I think managers in baseball have less of an impact on games than coaches in any other major sport, but they still tend to get a lot of the blame when things go wrong and a lot of credit with things go right. Baldelli has certainly seen both sides of this coin now in his tenure with the Twins. I know expectations were sky high going into this season, but I don't think the answer to the Twins' problems is to fire a manager that has just won back-to-back division titles because of a rough 30-game stretch.

Link to comment
Add a comment...

×   Pasted as rich text.   Paste as plain text instead

  Only 75 emoji are allowed.

×   Your link has been automatically embedded.   Display as a link instead

×   Your previous content has been restored.   Clear editor

×   You cannot paste images directly. Upload or insert images from URL.

  • Create New...