Jump to content

Providing independent coverage of the Minnesota Twins.
Subscribe to Twins Daily Email

The Forums

5/9: Twins vs. Tigers Postponed (Weather)

Minnesota Twins Talk Yesterday, 10:36 PM
Sunday afternoon's Mother's Day rubber match against the Tigers was postponed due to rain. The game is rescheduled as part of a split dou...

Twins Minor League Report (5/9): Double Headers Galore

Twins Minor League Talk Yesterday, 09:47 PM
There were six different games played in the system Sunday. We got a walk-off win, a few strong starts, and much more. Let’s get you caug...

Twins Minor League Report (5/8): Rain Rain, Go Away

Twins Minor League Talk Yesterday, 09:24 PM
A pair of starting pitchers on the 40-man roster were set to make their 2021 debuts on Saturday but only two games were able to be played...

Akil Baddoo crushes Homerun in first major league at bat

Other Baseball Yesterday, 09:06 PM
Big mistake letting this guy go

Buxton to the IL, Larnach added, Waddell DFA

Minnesota Twins Talk Yesterday, 07:15 PM
It's Larnach time already? Booya!!


Buying In On Twins Pitching Prospects

Posted by Ted Schwerzler , 17 September 2019 · 3,155 views

minnesota twins jorge alcala jhoan duran nelson cruz
Tomorrow is the annual release of Topps’ Bowman Chrome product. Each year there is a Bowman Draft and Bowman Chrome offering during the baseball card collecting calendar. As one would expect, the former highlights some of the top picks in the amateur draft while the latter picks up the slack on some of the others. For the Minnesota Twins, Chrome provides and interesting opportunity this time around.

While collecting baseball cards is traditionally a hobby, it’s also now a robust gambling and investor market. From ripping open a box looking for the next hot player or holding onto a card in hopes of it being the next Mike Trout, there’s money to be made and this isn’t just a child’s corner store pickup anymore. That isn’t more apparent anywhere than within the checklist of a Bowman product. These are all players that are defined as prospects or up and coming. Their elusive first autographs can be the most coveted cards in the hobby.

For Minnesota the signers this time around are Jorge Alcala and Jhoan Duran. It’s an intriguing duo in that both were acquired during the 2018 season in trades. Both have now spent a year within the organization, and the arrows for each are trending straight up. Alcala has earned his big-league call although he’s yet to debut, while Duran is still working exclusively as a starter topping out at Double-A.

There’s a difference between baseball good, and baseball card good, so let’s explore that within the parameters these two have provided us.

First and foremost, pitchers are a risky investment. The volatility of injury and sample size is truly one you must cope with. Then there’s the reality of a given market, and no one will argue that Twins players would be more coveted than the likes of Dodgers or Yankees. Beyond that you then get into a merit-based discussion.

Alcala is the fireballer acquired in exchange for Ryan Pressly from Houston. He comes from an organization with good developmental traits and is now in one that represents a similar level of execution. Starting didn’t work out well for Alcala this season, but since moving to relief he had a 0.98 ERA and .479 OPS against in 18.1 IP. The 18/4 K/BB is indicative of a guy that should rack up strikeouts, and his promotion to the big leagues during a Postseason run suggests that Minnesota sees him as a future difference maker as well.

The downside here is that Alcala is already 24 and he appears to be destined for the pen. While the opportunity to become a substantial asset for the Twins is real, the upside in the card collecting community is all but nullified. Josh Hader is one of the best arms on the planet, but his cardboard will never be at a premium because of the market and position he finds himself in. Alcala’s ink should be affordable and that will make him fun to collect, but this isn’t a guy that’s going to appreciate substantially.

When fan favorite Eduardo Escobar was traded the clubhouse went pretty sour. He found out on TV first, and it was among the initial moves that had the Twins parting out pieces as sellers. Duran headlined the return and has looked the part of a solid starting arm since coming over to Minnesota. He’s not a top 100 prospect and finds himself in the middle of the Twins top 10, but that doesn’t negate the production we’ve seen.

Still just 21-years-old, Duran reached Double-A Pensacola during 2019. His 3.76 ERA across two levels is plenty respectable, but the 10.6 K/9 is what jumps off the page. He can push it into the upper 90’s and sits comfortably in the mid-90’s. Homers have never been an issue for him, and we’ll see how that changes with the live ball at Triple-A and the big leagues, but this is an arm that could make its way into the Minnesota rotation by next year.

There isn’t ace-type upside here, and he too will have the designation of playing for the Twins, but a mid-rotation starter with upside is a pretty good bet. Duran would need to go on some sort of hot stretch or have a record setting year to vault himself into significant hobby-lore, but the ability for a short burst jump is certainly there. Another guy that should have very affordable autographs, he’s someone that you could see slight gains following a strong showing immediately after his promotion. More baseball good than hobby good, upside does have a bit of presence with him.

Make sure to check out 2019 Bowman Chrome at your local hobby shops when it drops on September 18. Along with these prospects, Minnesota has a few rookie autograph offerings as well as one of Nelson Cruz’s few depictions in a Twins uniform.

For more from Off The Baggy, click here. Follow at @tlschwerz

  • h2oface likes this

Compared to what Escobar and Pressly are doing.......... oh.... forget that. Prospects. We love our prospects.


Has Acala really "earned" a call up? Or is it just a curiosity at this point?

New FO has done a stunningly brilliant job in redefining the Twins. However, for what Escobar’s reasonable 3 year Diamondbacks deal was signed for, it would be very interesting to know the inside details why Twins and Escobar couldn’t agree to the same deal before or after the trade. Pressly trade not so good. Would have liked to see current pitching coach Wes Johnson have had a chance to refine Pressly like Houston did. Many AAA September call ups are indeed just auditioning for 2020.
    • Vagnavs likes this

You could say it was kind of like swapping Eduardo Escobar for Marwin Gonzalez who is the 2nd best comp for similar batters (career wise) to Eddie on BB Ref, plus some decent prospects. We'll have to wait and see how the young guys pan out.

Sep 30 2019 09:53 AM

Escobar wanted to test the free agent market pure and simple. We're still going to win the Pressly trade. Selling high is always a good move. Always.