Thread: #5 prospect prelim

Let's keep just voting for 1 on these, unless people want to open it up a bit more? Winner joins the 2 losers from #4 runoff

Went with Gibson over May. Just because Gibson is so much closer to MLB ready and should at the very least stick as a #3 in the majors. Also I tend to think Gibson can be a solid #2 as well.

who are the first 3? i am guessing Sano, Buxton, and Meyer or Hicks? And for this round I vote for either Meyer or Hicks at #5 depending on whoever isn't number 3. there should be a rundown of who was picked for each of these threads.

Like Spirit said - Gibson is ready for prime time this year.

Are the first four Buxton, Sano, Hicks, and Arcia? Where is Rosario?

Originally Posted by birdwatcher

Are the first four Buxton, Sano, Hicks, and Arcia? Where is Rosario?

This is to brandon as well. Updated lists are on the main thread. Rosario along with Meyer and Arcia are currently being voted on for the #4 spot, the winner of this will face the two "losers" of the #4 prospect run off.

Voted for Berrios as his ceiling is probably the highest of all of those listed.

If you voted write in you should probably comment on who it is so they can be included in the next runoff poll.