This shouldn't be that hard.
Maeda(been fantastic this year), Berrios(best stuff of all of them but hasn't been a shutdown type at all during postseason), Pineda(most consistent over the course of a couple years.
Then pitch them again next round. Use Hill if a 4th starter is needed. Put Dobby or Odo in the bullpen to use if any of those guys get knocked out early. Or if you get up big and need to rest your horses.