Cano maybe? Longoria or McCutchen?

I'd say Jeter and Miguel Cabrera.

Currently, Jeter. Ever, man that's harder. Probably Jeter, too. Maybe Molitor or Boggs?

Jeter, Utley, McGwire, Tony Gwynn.

I'll take Utley, two inferior teammates of his won MVP's.

Longoria belongs nowhere near the list, even with current guys. A few current names I'll toss in that haven't been mentioned - Jim Thome, Scott Rolen, Adrian Beltre, and Carlos Beltran.

Ill put Kirby on that list

Honus Wagner has the highest WAR of any HOFers w/o an MVP
Met Ott, Nap Lajoie & Eddie Mathews never won one either as HOFs

Mike Trout is the best player in the league right now and he has not won an MVP.. although I would say that is going to change fairly quickly!