I am surprised that Kyle Gibson is not in the Top 20. What happened to him? Is he still have No.3 upside or just back-end type starter?
The league was quite strong this year, and Gibson was strongly considered, but our feedback was definitely more back-of-the-rotation than No. 3. I would imagine him getting hammered in the major leagues colored the impression of IL managers. To me, this list is a pretty strong consensus up through about No. 15, then there were a lot of directions we could have gone.
Ben (Leland Grove):
Is Chris Colabello an example of someone who isn't as good as his numbers? How close was he to making your list?
Colabello is another example of someone who could have made the list, and I think his MLB struggles colored the evaluation. Also he struggled a bit defensively; reports of him coming into the year defensively at first actually were strong, but the feedback we got on him at first or in the outfield corners was not positive this year. He’s a tremendous story, and that kind of opposite-field power is hard to find. I think he’s a platoon option going forward and not quite a regular, not dissimilar than Darin Ruf at 17, but Ruf has shown more power at the MLB level and a bit better defense, which is saying something.