Minnesota Twins News & Rumors Forum
Page 1 of 2 12 LastLast
Results 1 to 20 of 24

Thread: Video challenges come to MLB

  1. #1
    Senior Member All-Star IdahoPilgrim's Avatar
    Posts
    2,421
    Like
    2
    Liked 10 Times in 8 Posts
    Blog Entries
    26

    Video challenges come to MLB

    According to the article, starting next year managers will have a challenge system for video replay similar to what the NFL does. Note particularly that, on disputed plays, the final call will be made be an official in the league offices and not the crew on the field, similar to what the NHL does right now.

    The only thing off-limits is balls & strikes.

    MLB expands instant replay in 2014 to include manager video challenges - ESPN

    http://www.usatoday.com/story/sports...-hold/2659555/

    Personally, I think eventually balls & strikes too will be subject to more electronic scrutiny. Welcome to the 21st century, MLB.
    Last edited by IdahoPilgrim; 08-15-2013 at 01:42 PM.

  2. #2
    Twins News Team All-Star TheLeviathan's Avatar
    Posts
    4,667
    Like
    155
    Liked 608 Times in 339 Posts
    Oof, if this slows baseball down as much as it has football....this could get ugly fast.

    I hope they've really planned for that - the NHL is VERY quick most of the time, let's hope it follows that model.

  3. #3
    Senior Member All-Star IdahoPilgrim's Avatar
    Posts
    2,421
    Like
    2
    Liked 10 Times in 8 Posts
    Blog Entries
    26
    Quote Originally Posted by TheLeviathan View Post
    Oof, if this slows baseball down as much as it has football....this could get ugly fast.

    I hope they've really planned for that - the NHL is VERY quick most of the time, let's hope it follows that model.
    I concur. Hopefully with the way it is structured, with only 1 challenge each in the first 6 innings, games that are blowouts or not close will not have all 3 used per team. I also like having a trained crew in New York, presumably with rule book in hand, to handle disputed calls. Sometimes umpires on the field do misremember a rule and make a mistake. Doesn't happen often, but...

  4. #4
    Senior Member All-Star James's Avatar
    Posts
    1,247
    Like
    261
    Liked 128 Times in 83 Posts
    How are managers supposed to get thrown out of the game now if they can just challenge the play?
    You can come up with statistics to prove anything. Forty percent of all people know that.

  5. #5
    Senior Member All-Star IdahoPilgrim's Avatar
    Posts
    2,421
    Like
    2
    Liked 10 Times in 8 Posts
    Blog Entries
    26
    Quote Originally Posted by James View Post
    How are managers supposed to get thrown out of the game now if they can just challenge the play?
    I'm guessing that Gardy's wife is doing cartwheels right about now.

  6. #6
    Senior Member All-Star
    Posts
    1,701
    Like
    7
    Liked 20 Times in 10 Posts
    Challenges are a terrible idea. I would just use a buzz system. There are missed calls but it is much fewer than people think, maybe one a game average.

  7. #7
    Senior Member All-Star IdahoPilgrim's Avatar
    Posts
    2,421
    Like
    2
    Liked 10 Times in 8 Posts
    Blog Entries
    26
    One thing it may do is cut down the acting by managers - sometimes they come out to argue, not because they actually think the call was wrong, but for tactical reasons, to break up some momentum or to support a player or to influence a future call, etc.

  8. #8
    Twins Moderator MVP USAFChief's Avatar
    Posts
    6,495
    Like
    3,509
    Liked 3,012 Times in 1,280 Posts
    Good lord, leave it to baseball to finally accept replay, but then muck up the implementation horribly.

    Just have a 5th ump in a booth watching the game in real time. In 99% of the cases, we know via replay at home whether or not a call was blown before the ball is put in play again. When a call is blow, he lets the head ump know and the whole thing is fixed in a few seconds.

    A challange system is just stupid.

  9. #9
    Twins Moderator All-Star twinsnorth49's Avatar
    Posts
    3,506
    Like
    844
    Liked 1,180 Times in 627 Posts
    Quote Originally Posted by USAFChief View Post
    Good lord, leave it to baseball to finally accept replay, but then muck up the implementation horribly.

    Just have a 5th ump in a booth watching the game in real time. In 99% of the cases, we know via replay at home whether or not a call was blown before the ball is put in play again. When a call is blow, he lets the head ump know and the whole thing is fixed in a few seconds.

    A challange system is just stupid.
    I agree in principle with that Chief, but somebody has to call for a review on any given play, it can't be the guy in the booth or else every play is subject to his discretion, that can't work.

  10. #10
    Twins Moderator MVP USAFChief's Avatar
    Posts
    6,495
    Like
    3,509
    Liked 3,012 Times in 1,280 Posts
    Quote Originally Posted by twinsnorth49 View Post
    I agree in principle with that Chief, but somebody has to call for a review on any given play, it can't be the guy in the booth or else every play is subject to his discretion, that can't work.
    I don't see why not. Like I said, we usually know if there's a blown call before the ball is ever put back into play. I doubt there'd be much disruption as 99% of the time the umps get it correct. IMO a 5th ump would be in the background and pretty invisible.

    having managers challenge is going to muck up the flow, lead to second guessing, and inevitably end up with a call badly blown that alters a game but goes uncorrected because a manager is out of challenges or learns of the blown call too late.

    does ANYone think the NFL gets replay correct?

  11. #11
    Senior Member Big-Leaguer
    Posts
    985
    Like
    188
    Liked 217 Times in 94 Posts
    I can't wait until someone challenges but is not allowed to on a technicality like Schwartz on Thanksgiving.

  12. #12
    Speediest Moderator All-Star snepp's Avatar
    Posts
    4,039
    Like
    1,763
    Liked 1,236 Times in 492 Posts
    Everything Chief said, I'm in full concurment.



    And yes, that is a word, urban dictionary says so.
    "Maybe you could go grab a bat and ball… and learn something. Maybe you will get it."
    - Strib commenter educating the elitists on the value of RBI's

  13. #13
    Twins Moderator MVP USAFChief's Avatar
    Posts
    6,495
    Like
    3,509
    Liked 3,012 Times in 1,280 Posts
    Quote Originally Posted by snepp View Post



    And yes, that is a word, urban dictionary says so.
    Concur.

  14. #14
    Senior Member Big-Leaguer
    Posts
    985
    Like
    188
    Liked 217 Times in 94 Posts
    They should also have a challenge system for when their players screw up.

  15. #15
    Twins Moderator All-Star twinsnorth49's Avatar
    Posts
    3,506
    Like
    844
    Liked 1,180 Times in 627 Posts
    Quote Originally Posted by USAFChief View Post
    I don't see why not. Like I said, we usually know if there's a blown call before the ball is ever put back into play. I doubt there'd be much disruption as 99% of the time the umps get it correct. IMO a 5th ump would be in the background and pretty invisible.

    having managers challenge is going to muck up the flow, lead to second guessing, and inevitably end up with a call badly blown that alters a game but goes uncorrected because a manager is out of challenges or learns of the blown call too late.

    does ANYone think the NFL gets replay correct?
    Like I said, I agree with you, the manager challenge is a poor idea and lord knows the NFL is a shining exaple of that. I'm just talking about implementation of the 5th ump and how and when a call is determined to be blown, essentially what you're saying is that the 5th ump calls the entire game.

    I'm really just talking logistics, I suppose it could work, the communication would have to be pretty seamless though.

  16. #16
    Twins Moderator MVP USAFChief's Avatar
    Posts
    6,495
    Like
    3,509
    Liked 3,012 Times in 1,280 Posts
    Quote Originally Posted by twinsnorth49 View Post
    Like I said, I agree with you, the manager challenge is a poor idea and lord knows the NFL is a shining exaple of that. I'm just talking about implementation of the 5th ump and how and when a call is determined to be blown, essentially what you're saying is that the 5th ump calls the entire game.

    I'm really just talking logistics, I suppose it could work, the communication would have to be pretty seamless though.
    You are correct, as usual. There would be issues. IMO those issues could be worked out, just like the issues they'll have with a challenge system. They'll need the same amount of video capabilities for the challenge system, for example.

  17. #17
    Senior Member All-Star
    Posts
    1,701
    Like
    7
    Liked 20 Times in 10 Posts
    I want replay but the more I think about it the more I wish they had done nothing instead of a challenge system.

  18. #18
    Senior Member All-Star
    Posts
    1,460
    Like
    64
    Liked 144 Times in 93 Posts
    Blog Entries
    30
    The real discussion should be about how a team can gain an advantage by utilizing the rules well. I would like to hear the Twins responses to these questions.

    Are the Twins preparing now? Are they simulating when they might use it during a game? Are they practicing the communication and decision making process?

    Every event in baseball has a run value. Will the bench know the value of reversing the event? Will they use the general table or a custom one that varies with the specific pitcher, batter and game condition? Some events may be easier to see in replay than others and therefore more likely to be reversed. Are the Twins studying this by looking at old video and multiple cameras?

    I hope the Twins have someone working and preparing the analytics and decision making process. Some teams are going to find a way to get advantage a squeeze out a win or two. I am guessing the Rays and Joe Maddon will be preparing. Other teams will not be as prepared. Their decision making process may be reactionary and more dependent on the emotion of the moment. Those teams might find it costs them a win or two.

  19. #19
    Senior Member All-Star IdahoPilgrim's Avatar
    Posts
    2,421
    Like
    2
    Liked 10 Times in 8 Posts
    Blog Entries
    26
    Quote Originally Posted by jorgenswest View Post
    The real discussion should be about how a team can gain an advantage by utilizing the rules well. I would like to hear the Twins responses to these questions.

    Are the Twins preparing now? Are they simulating when they might use it during a game? Are they practicing the communication and decision making process?

    Every event in baseball has a run value. Will the bench know the value of reversing the event? Will they use the general table or a custom one that varies with the specific pitcher, batter and game condition? Some events may be easier to see in replay than others and therefore more likely to be reversed. Are the Twins studying this by looking at old video and multiple cameras?

    I hope the Twins have someone working and preparing the analytics and decision making process. Some teams are going to find a way to get advantage a squeeze out a win or two. I am guessing the Rays and Joe Maddon will be preparing. Other teams will not be as prepared. Their decision making process may be reactionary and more dependent on the emotion of the moment. Those teams might find it costs them a win or two.


    I think they've hired an intern for this.

  20. #20
    Twins Moderator MVP USAFChief's Avatar
    Posts
    6,495
    Like
    3,509
    Liked 3,012 Times in 1,280 Posts
    Quote Originally Posted by jorgenswest View Post
    The real discussion should be about how a team can gain an advantage by utilizing the rules well.
    I thought the real discussion was about getting more calls correct.

    Silly me.

Page 1 of 2 12 LastLast

Posting Permissions

  • You may not post new threads
  • You may not post replies
  • You may not post attachments
  • You may not edit your posts
  •  
©2014 TwinsCentric, LLC. All Rights Reserved.
Interested in advertising with Twins Daily? Click here.