Minnesota Twins News & Rumors Forum

View Poll Results: Appel, Gray and Bryant are gone. Your pick is:

Voters
67. You may not vote on this poll
  • Kohl Stewart

    52 77.61%
  • College pitcher

    10 14.93%
  • Reese McGuire

    2 2.99%
  • Someone else

    3 4.48%
Page 1 of 2 12 LastLast
Results 1 to 20 of 39

Thread: Poll: Draft Scenario 1

  1. #1
    Owner All-Star John Bonnes's Avatar
    Posts
    2,427
    Twitter
    @twinsgeek
    Like
    1
    Liked 157 Times in 93 Posts
    Blog Entries
    240

    Poll: Draft Scenario 1

    Let's assume that the first three picks are Appel, Gray and Bryant (as seems likely). Let's also assume that Kohl Stewart will sign at slot, but probably not below. However, Reese McGuire will sign for less than slot - say #7 money, which would save $1.3M for future draft picks. Who do you choose:

    a. Kohl Stewart, RHP with the most upside but most risk AND he won't be arriving to majors until 2017 most likely
    b. a college pitcher like Stanek, Shipley, Manaea, etc. - less risk, less upside, but a probably arrives by 2015.
    c. Reese McGuire and use the $1.3M on other picks?

    I'll add a poll, but I'll be more interested in your comments.
    Last edited by John Bonnes; 05-30-2013 at 04:23 PM.

  2. #2
    Banned Big-Leaguer
    Posts
    715
    Like
    82
    Liked 40 Times in 29 Posts
    Jim Callis said Stewart could make it to Target Field sometime in 2015. He did not expand on it. It was about 2 or 3 draft chats ago.

  3. #3
    Senior Member All-Star Badsmerf's Avatar
    Posts
    1,564
    Like
    17
    Liked 59 Times in 34 Posts
    Blog Entries
    6
    I'd still go Stewart. I haven't seen any reason to not take him other than his age. He might take a little longer to make it through the system than a college guy, but he has #1 upside that just isn't available very often. Stewart is only a little over a year younger than Sano. I doubt they would put him in Cedar Rapids right away, but if they allow him to see time there at the end of the season I don't think 2106 is too aggressive to see him (perhaps as a playoff push?). That is all in the ideal world.
    Do or do not. There is no try.

  4. #4
    Senior Member Triple-A InfraRen's Avatar
    Posts
    300
    Twitter
    @InfraRen
    Like
    42
    Liked 14 Times in 9 Posts
    When you're picking this high - or anywhere for that matter, people have been talking about, this type of player has bigger bust potential (HS pitcher/hitter vs College pitcher/hitter.) Seems like the HS pitcher scares people away, but in reality, it's really a crapshoot from all types of players.

    That said, if this scenario plays out - drafting this high, you HAVE to take best available, and the one with the highest potential. Especially with a team like the Twins who made major moves in rebuilding this off season. Keep building that farm. You will be rewarded.

    With all that - my pick is Kohl Stewart. He has a frame that is more muscular than most HS pitchers (which is favorable w/ injury risk moving through the minors), has a solid mix of 3 (some dominant) pitches now, with room for more and is (based on Callis, McDaniel, Law, etc.) the BPA there Based on raw stuff it's up there with Gray/Appel's. In my mind he's the perfect combo of need AND BPA.

    Make the pick, Twins.

    (Plus, he'll utilize the 10,000 lakes.)
    kohl.JPG
    Last edited by InfraRen; 05-30-2013 at 04:40 PM.
    Till I Collapse

  5. #5
    Senior Member All-Star
    Posts
    1,755
    Like
    1
    Liked 102 Times in 72 Posts
    A) and it is not even close. Stewart is the only pitcher in the draft not named Gray or Appel who profiles as a true ace. He also has very advanced stuff for his age. Is there a little more risk taking a HS pitcher vs a college pitcher? I'm not so sure about that in this draft.

    Shipley has an insanely short track record because he was a converted SS and until 2 weeks ago had throw several clunkers in a row. He has #2 upside but hasn't had the K numbers you would like from a guy with his stuff.

    Manaea was a super popular pick before the year started because of insane Cape Cod numbers from increased "stuff". Problem is he hasn't shown the same "stuff" since the Cape Cod league and had never shown it before which leaves many questions unanswered. Add in an injury and experts are starting to wonder if he will even go in the first round.

    Stanek has been so inconsistent this year while having a very violent delivery that lots of scouts think he might be a relief pitcher in the bigs. Upside wise Stank, Shipley, and Manaea are a clear step below Stewart while IMO not being an safer. Heck, not only are they not safer I don't think anything about them shouts quicker to the bigs and isn't that the argument to take college pitcher with less upside than HS pitchers?

    Regarding McGuire.... I just don't see the depth in this draft to justify it. Super deep draft? Maybe. This year? No thanks.

  6. #6
    Senior Member All-Star
    Posts
    1,218
    Like
    97
    Liked 95 Times in 69 Posts
    My pick is Trey Ball. Power LHPs are truly rare and have a floor as trade bait or RP. Face it, there just aren't enough LHP with major league arms, "when you get the chance Take IT!"

  7. #7
    Owner All-Star John Bonnes's Avatar
    Posts
    2,427
    Twitter
    @twinsgeek
    Like
    1
    Liked 157 Times in 93 Posts
    Blog Entries
    240
    I'd like to apologize for setting up the poll so that only registered members can vote. I assume that is a default flag that I didn't know was turned on. For future polls, we'll try and turn that off.

    By the way, great comments.

  8. #8
    First off, unless Appel drops to 4th there is no player that's going to help the twins in 2014 so pick the best player.

    Kohl Stewart. HS pitchers are notorious draft washouts. Scouts love the power but they tend not to polish up as they finish filling out. I disagree that he is any more muscular than the typical HS pitcher. He weights the same as Berrios and Berrios is the smallest looking 6-0 in person that I've ever seen.

    The scouting video I've seen shows he looks at his feet mid-motion on every pitch and picks up the target late. His release point is very inconsistent and his pitches wander all over the plate area as a result. Whether the Twins can convince him that his feet aren't going anywhere I don't know. I've never seen coaches use a dog funnel but he needs it. A lot of kids can't break this habit.

    On the flip side is that he throws some REALLY sweet pitches.

    Reese McGuire. Defensively he's the real deal. I agree with the comments that he's almost major league ready although no idea how he would be at calling a game. Got the arm, catches the ball, frames well and throws down to 2nd well.

    Batting he needs to work at getting his arms better extended/hitting the ball out in front of him a bit better. Quiet swing, loads up and moves towards the ball with a little leg lift/step. He's seen Puckett video. I agree that he doesn't seem like he'll hit got a lot of power but I think he makes much better contact than he has been given credit for.

    Bottom line, take McQuire if he'll go under slot and see if the Twins can pick up a hard to sign HS arm with a protected pick. Or even a draft end pick. This strategy makes more sense if the Astros are successful in hinting to HS players they will do the same with a 1-1 Moran pick.
    Last edited by boylan; 05-30-2013 at 05:35 PM.

  9. #9
    Owner MVP Seth Stohs's Avatar
    Posts
    6,433
    Twitter
    @sethtweets
    Like
    64
    Liked 346 Times in 182 Posts
    Blog Entries
    515
    I'm pretty much good with anything (Which I'm sure surprises many of you).

    I'd be good with Stanek because of how well he's come on, he's advanced, he has been considered a top 10 pick all year.
    i'd be good with Stewart, especially if they believe he'll sign. He may have the best upside.
    I'd be OK (at best) with McGuire and have to trust that he will have enough bat to be a #1 catcher in the big leagues for several years. No one is expecting Mauer, but want something. He's a consensus Top 10 guy too, which means he's pretty good. if they do that, I'll be curious how the savings will affect later picks.

    Frankly, after the Big 3, it's a crapshoot, so get the one that allows most flexibility

  10. #10
    Senior Member All-Star
    Posts
    1,450
    Like
    140
    Liked 132 Times in 69 Posts
    I think the term "close to MLB ready" is a terrible reason to pass on someone you think is better.
    Good things come to those who wait.
    So, I voted Stewart over the college arms.
    Gibson and Wimmers were both drafted, in part, because of how close to MLB ready they were, but because of things that can't be predicted, there will likely be HS draftees who got to the majors quicker than they do.

  11. #11
    Senior Member Double-A
    Posts
    142
    Like
    0
    Liked 18 Times in 6 Posts
    I'm in the Trey Ball camp, as well. However, I think you let him play OF initially. Give him a couple years to fill out physically, and save the wear and tear on his young arm. If at that point you don't think the bat is gonna play, you've got a physically developed 6'6" southpaw with a cannon who should progress pretty fast.

  12. #12
    Senior Member All-Star
    Posts
    1,450
    Like
    140
    Liked 132 Times in 69 Posts
    Slightly OT, I think it's time that MLB changes the rules to allow trading of draft picks. If you think you are good enough to identify a player that is being undervalued, you should be able to benefit by trading down and accumulating more value, as you can in the NFL.

  13. #13
    Senior Member Big-Leaguer Twins Twerp's Avatar
    Posts
    757
    Like
    27
    Liked 104 Times in 66 Posts
    The more I hear about McGuire...the more I like it

  14. #14
    Twins Moderator All-Star diehardtwinsfan's Avatar
    Posts
    4,212
    Like
    366
    Liked 742 Times in 459 Posts
    Blog Entries
    3
    Quote Originally Posted by Badsmerf View Post
    I'd still go Stewart. I haven't seen any reason to not take him other than his age. He might take a little longer to make it through the system than a college guy, but he has #1 upside that just isn't available very often. Stewart is only a little over a year younger than Sano. I doubt they would put him in Cedar Rapids right away, but if they allow him to see time there at the end of the season I don't think 2106 is too aggressive to see him (perhaps as a playoff push?). That is all in the ideal world.
    He'll be dead by then, and if 2106 is the goal, I think most of us will not be Twins fans anymore.

  15. #15
    Twins Moderator All-Star diehardtwinsfan's Avatar
    Posts
    4,212
    Like
    366
    Liked 742 Times in 459 Posts
    Blog Entries
    3
    I think it's Stewart and not close. As others have pointed out, aces are typically found in the first round, and while Stewart might be a tad riskier than say Shipley or Moran, he's likely to be a much bigger impact player.

  16. #16
    Senior Member All-Star
    Posts
    1,755
    Like
    1
    Liked 102 Times in 72 Posts
    Quote Originally Posted by Twins Twerp View Post
    The more I hear about McGuire...the more I like it
    Personally the main question I have about taking McGuire isn't his overall talent level, kid is a top 10 prospect in the draft, but the depth of the draft. I just don't see a lot of over slot guys worthy of extra money later on in the draft.

  17. #17
    Quote Originally Posted by cmb0252 View Post
    Personally the main question I have about taking McGuire isn't his overall talent level, kid is a top 10 prospect in the draft, but the depth of the draft. I just don't see a lot of over slot guys worthy of extra money later on in the draft.
    I think this is a very good point. What, 1/3 of the first round will play in the majors? To balance out a Moran (Astros) or McGuire pick you would probably need to sign several HS players in later rounds that wouldn't otherwise sign (and who were worthy of 2nd money) because the money wasn't enough. Can you get 3 kids in the 40+ round to sign for 500,000 - 700,000? No clue. But you've only got about a day to figure it out once the first round ends.

  18. #18
    Senior Member All-Star Thrylos's Avatar
    Posts
    4,135
    Twitter
    @thrylos98
    Like
    34
    Liked 432 Times in 262 Posts
    Blog Entries
    200
    It looks like the Astros will take Moran, per multiple sources, so the Twins would really have a choice to make. I assume that either Gray or Appel to the Cubs and Bryant to Colorado, and that leaves one of the 2 "big" college pitchers.

    I'd still take Manaea for the reasons I explained here. If one of the aforementioned pitchers can throw left handed, I'd change my mind
    -----
    Blogging Twins since 2007 at The Tenth Inning Stretch
    http://tenthinningstretch.blogspot.com/
    twitter: @thrylos98

  19. #19
    Senior Member All-Star YourHouseIsMyHouse's Avatar
    Posts
    1,235
    Like
    8
    Liked 17 Times in 12 Posts
    Blog Entries
    10
    1. Stewart
    2. McGuire
    3. Ball
    4. Shipley

    I can live with all those picks. Anything else and I'm furious.

  20. #20
    Senior Member Big-Leaguer Brad Swanson's Avatar
    Posts
    575
    Twitter
    @Bridman77
    Like
    64
    Liked 56 Times in 29 Posts
    Blog Entries
    154
    My dream scenario: McGuire at 4, Karsten Whitson at 43.

    Although, I wouldn't actually do that. I'd take Stewart and pay him what it takes. Personally, I think there are quite a few interesting high school players who could slip to 43 that might sign if paid well (Chris Okey and Ryan Boldt to name two) and Whitson has huge upside, but I wouldn't take the risk that all the guys like them will be there later.
    Last edited by Brad Swanson; 05-30-2013 at 07:33 PM.
    Works on contingency? No, money down!
    Kevin Slowey was Framed!

Page 1 of 2 12 LastLast

Posting Permissions

  • You may not post new threads
  • You may not post replies
  • You may not post attachments
  • You may not edit your posts
  •  
©2014 TwinsCentric, LLC. All Rights Reserved.
Interested in advertising with Twins Daily? Click here.