The few cheapshots notwithstanding, I'm enjoying this thread. I haven't been happy with Gardenhire for years, but I've had a hard time putting my finger on why. He seems so different from TK. I once described it as the difference between reason over emotion and emotion over reason. Too me, Gardy's too much heart, and not enough brain. I cannot imagine him leading a team to the WS. And he's worked with a great deal of talent in some of those Central Division titles, to very little result. So, for those who champion Gardy, at least I'm getting a better picture of why -- even if I admit I'm not yet in agreement.
Originally Posted by nicksaviking