View RSS Feed

Morneau vs. The Void

Rate this Entry
If The Twins Are Willing To Trade Morneau This Offseason, There Should Be Options

Last week, as the trade deadline approached, Justin Morneau was featured in the latest trade rumors. That made sense. First, Morneau had been productive and healthy. Second, Chris Parmelee is raking at first base in AAA but shut out in the majors. Finally, Morneau is still owed about $19M for the rest of this year and next. Moving him would give the Twins that much more money to spend on pitching this offseason.

No deal was consummated, and it doesnt sound like one was close, but that doesnt mean the end of the rumors. Theyll flow into this offseason and will likely gain additional steam because this year the crop of free agent first basemen is so bleak. There is no Prince Fielder or Albert Pujols or even a Paul Konerko in this class.

The top name? Would you believe the 37-year-old Carlos Lee? Yes, the same Carlos Lee who was already salary dumped this year and then was rumored to be on the block again. He has all of six home runs, but at least hes hitting .292. Now look into the rest of the void.

Sure, Theyre Old, But At Least Theyre Hurt.
Lance Berkman
He has just 75 at-bat this year because hes been out the last two months after knee surgery, and that was following a previous stay on the DL for a calf injury. There will be serious concerns that his 36-year-old body cant take it any more.

Aubrey Huff
Similarly, Huff is 35 years old and has only has 61 at-bats this year (and is hitting just .148) because of several DL stints which include an anxiety disorder and knee tendonitis.

Carlos Pena
Ok, hes not hurt, but hes hitting .193, so who could tell? He's also 35 years old and still cant hit left-handers. Like the others, hes worth a flyer, but who would rely on him for more than that?

Bad, But Bad In A Youngish Way
Casey Kotchman
Hes just 30 years old, but he has never hit more than 12 home runs in his career, is struggling against left-handers and is hitting just .223.

James Loney
Hes the reason the Dodgers were talking to the Twins about Morneau at the deadline. Hes hitting .257 with two home runs. Two As in two more than I have hitting for the Dodgers this year. The only thing he has going for him is that hes only 28 years old.

Theyre Old. They Also Dont Start.
Ty Wigginton
All you need to know about the 35-year-old Wigginton is that the only way hes available is if the Phils DONT pick up a $4M option on him. That should clarify his value.

Eric Hinske
Yes, Im talking about the 35-year-old bench player for the Braves for the lat 3 years. He has not seen 400 at-bats from a team since 2005.

Winner: Justin Morneau
Morneau, by comparison, is 31 years old, hitting .275 and has 15 home runs. Those numbers dont justify a $14M salary next year. And if he was a free agent, he would not garner any offers for that kind of money annually.

However, he is also the class of that list. If Morneau was a free agent, right now it looks like a two-year deal (for maybe $16M?) would not be out of the question. A three-year deal might be in play. If he and his agent insisted on a one-year deal (to increase his value for another run at free agency), a $9-10M deal might not be out of the question.

But more important than the numbers is simply supply and demand. This offseason, the supply of first basemen who can be a middle-of-the-order presence for a competitive team is limited. In fact, it could be just Morneau. If Terry Ryan decides he is willing to trade Morneau either to make room for Parmelee or to free up $14M in cash there sure should be some desperate teams out there.
Tags: None Add / Edit Tags


  1. nokomismod's Avatar
    Wow, he really is the cream of the crop. I'd really like to see what Parmalee can do with the big league club before the Twins make any decisions.
  2. Fire Dan Gladden's Avatar
    John, I think you just made a pretty good case why the Twins shouldn't move Morneau. I'm in the camp that the Twins are not far away from competing for the division. Moving Morneau at this point doesn't make a lot of sense unless they get a goldmine for him (which they won't).
©2014 TwinsCentric, LLC. All Rights Reserved.
Interested in advertising with Twins Daily? Click here.