Minnesota Twins News & Rumors Forum
View RSS Feed

Peanuts from Heaven

Let's Make a Deal for Denard Span

Rate this Entry
​This blog is also available on our original site along with a quick and easy poll to vote in

In six weeks the trade deadline will come to pass, but before that happens there will be rumors, conjecture, and wheeling/dealing of innumerable kinds. It's exhilarating and yet, frightening because--after all--you're giving up something you know for something that is totally unpredictable.

There's so much uncertainty that it makes me feel every bit as anxious as I used to feel watching game shows as a kid. For some reason--even though many were decade's old repeats--I worried over each lightning round, groaned with each needless gamble and muttered "no whammy, no whammy, no whammy" over and over again.

But beyond a doubt, the trade-crazed part of the season reminds me of Monte Hall's legendary "Let's Make a Deal". For those who didn't waste their sick days gorging on bad tv: Let's Make a Deal gives average people the chance to just take away a couple hundred bucks or trade it in for something behind one of three doors. Some contain fabulous prizes, some contain goats chewing hay. You just never know
Yes, I have several brain cells devoted to knowing this show...
(Courtesy Letsmakeadeal.com)
Whatever you may say about scouting reports and statistical analyses, trades still boil down to fast choices between a few options--keep what you have or swap it out for an unknown risk. But rather than let Terry Ryan have all the fun/anxiety of these decisions, we fans can play along at home!

That's right, I'm channelling my inner Monte Hall/Wayne Brady and presenting three options for the Twins most likely trade candidates. Each one is based on trades made for similar players in baseball history, and while they aren't all deadline deals or deals with similar contract statuses, they represent deals that offer things the Twins might like to have in building for the future in exchange for a similar player at a similar age.

So, you'll all be playing as Terry Ryan and in the interest of fairness I'll give you a few hints at who's behind the door with stats and ages. Then you vote (either in the poll at the right, or the comments section below) for the trade you think TR should make. I'll unveil what's behind each door next week so we can see just what the blogo-sphere community would walk away with if we pooled our collective wisdom.

With that let's.......MAKE A DEAL!!!!!!!
Image credit: CBS.com
Okay, Terrys first up I'll give you a 28-year-old consistently above average Center Fielder: that's right it's Denard Span!!! Alright, would you like to keep Denard Span or would you like what's behind Door #1? Door #2? Or Door #3?

Oh, don't make up your mind so fast Terrys! Let's get a little hint at what you'd get behind each other door

Behind door #1 there's a durable reliever in AAA who had a 1.94 K/BB ratio and a 1.35 ERA in a cup of coffee with the big team. To sweeten the pot, there's a fast rising outfielder whose defense just gets better with each level (1.34 RF/G in A ball to 1.79 in AA) he cranked 26 homers in A ball and though that dropped to 16 in AA this year he's just 20 years old and should get better with age especially in your system when you MAKE THIS DEAL!!

Behind door #2 there's a man Baseball Prospectus ranks as a top 10 prospect on the team! He's versatile enough to have split time between second base and the outfield in rookie ball and he's even made the transition to 3rd in A ball this year! But the bat is the big appeal for this youngster boasting a current slash line of .312/.416/.411! We'll even throw in a fat wad of cash just for you if you MAKE THIS DEAL!!

And finally behind door #3 we have some options, you can have any 2 of the following 3 players, yes... in this scenario you can pick between an outfielder who marked a career high in Home Runs in AA last year (but is crowded out of our flush system); a catcher who's just about major league ready posting a .286/.339/.471 slash line in AAA (how 'bout that to replace Drew Butera?); OR a AA Starting pitcher who has 113 Ks in 103 innings and 1.92 K/BB Ratio! And hey, if you want all three just agree to toss in Ryan Doumit and we will MAKE THIS DEAL!!

So there you have it blogosphere Terry-clones! Do you want to keep Denard Span or will it be Door #1?! Door #2?! or Door #3!?!?!

(Vote and share your reasoning in the comments below--our trade deadline is Sunday at Midnight Central)

Updated 06-19-2012 at 12:32 PM by PeanutsFromHeaven



  1. Mchans24's Avatar
    Door # 3 I want pitching. Throw in Doumit for all three.
  2. YourHouseIsMyHouse's Avatar
    Door #3 and all three with Doumit.
  3. ashburyjohn's Avatar
    At this point I think I keep Span. I'd really like to know the ages of all these players, as a 25 year old SP in AA doesn't interest me but a 22 year old might.

    Given the framework explained for option 3, if the addition of Doumit pries loose the third prospect, then I would like to explore keeping Span and just making it Doumit for that one pitcher (if he's not 25!!!), throwing in a spare-part single-A prospect if necessary to MAKE THIS DEAL! I know this goes against the rules of the game you've set up, but I'm guilty of getting back to reality, I'm afraid, and sometimes trades arise out of a completely different discussion.

    By the way, good job on making these trade packages realistic - apparently you matched the past trades very well to what Span brings to the table. Most of these trades sound like pieces that don't fit in very well with their current team - which is kind of how Delmon Young found his way onto the Twins. As the old saying goes, the best trades are the ones you don't make - almost always the other GM knows what he's got and is trading it away for a reason.
    Updated 06-20-2012 at 11:56 AM by ashburyjohn
  4. PeanutsFromHeaven's Avatar
    Thanks for the votes gents, I'm hoping this can serve as a fun mental exercise (despite the inexact science of suggesting such deals)

    In the interest of full disclosure, ashburyjohn, the ages are as follows:
    Door #1 AAA RP-25 y.o.; AA OF-20 y.o.
    Door #2 2B/OF-21 y.o. (Cash...ageless)
    Door #3 AA OF-23 y.o; AAA C-25 y.o.; AA SP 23 y.o.

    Still interested? MChans24 & YHIMH feel free to change your minds if, with this info you want to change your mind.

    I'll include ages with all future Let's Make a Deal Options...next week...Matt Capps!
©2014 TwinsCentric, LLC. All Rights Reserved.
Interested in advertising with Twins Daily? Click here.