Minnesota Twins News & Rumors Forum
  • Ch-Ch-Ch-Changes

    Originally posted at Knuckleballsblog.com.

    I didnít rush right out to post reactions to the Twinsí coaching changes as the information came out on Thursday, which is probably a good thing.

    StarTribune beat reporter LaVelle E. Neal III was obviously wired in to the situation at Target Field and started the ball rolling by announcing that bullpen coach Rick Stelmaszek had been advised his contract was not being renewed. My immediate reaction, via Twitter, was something to the effect that blaming the Twinsí problems on Stelly was comparable to blaming the Titanicís problems on the guy who painted the hull of the ship. Based on what I read of othersí comments, I wasnít the only fan who felt that way.

    But, as we now know, the Twins gave more of the coaching staff similar messages. Jerry White and Steve Liddle were also not renewed while Scott Ullger and Joe Vavra were assigned instructional duties. Only Rick Anderson survived the purge and Andy got just a one-year reprieve. Of course, Ron Gardenhire himself has one more year on his contract and heís being allowed to continue in his role, at least for now.

    While the media was initially assuming (or at least speculating) that Ullger and Vavra would remain on the Major League staff, both coaches were listed as minor league instructors on the Twinsí official website. Their situations have been clarified apparently and both will remain with the Major League club, which disappoints me a bit. I donít necessarily think Vavra has done a bad job as the Twinsí hitting coach, but how easy will it be for a new coach to establish himself with the hitters with Vavra still in the clubhouse?

    What this all means is that the Twins have three open coaching positions to fill in their Major League dugout and while the Twins havenít announced who would be filling those positions, itís pretty clear who will be making the decisions. While most MLB managers are given a great deal of latitude in terms of assembling their own coaching staffs, clearly Gardenhire is not the primary decision maker this time around. He was on record recently as saying he wanted to keep all of his coaches, but General Manager (without the ďinterimĒ) Terry Ryan pretty much put an abrupt end to that possibility.

    Instead, Gardenhire and Anderson will have three new faces surrounding them next season and two of those new faces are likely to be Gene Glynn and Bobby Cuellar, who are very definitely potential replacements for Gardy and Andy should the teamís performance once again fall below expectations in 2013.

    Will these two be seeing more of one another in 2013? (Knuckleballs photo)

    The purge also could make room on the Major League staff for former Twins star Tom Brunansky. Bruno was hired to coach hitting for the Twins Gulf Coast League rookie team in July of 2010. A year later, he was the hitting coach at AA New Britain and this past season he moved up to AAA Rochester. His coaching abilities have not gone unnoticed, obviously, and apparently theyíve been noticed beyond just the Twins organization. Speculation has been that if the Twins donít find a way to promote him, other organizations will and the Twins are likely lose him.

    Ryan has indicated a desire to add a Spanish-speaking coach to their Big League staff since a number of MLB-ready players do not speak much English. That might bode well for Cuellarís chances, but one has to wonder just how much help heíd be with communication issues during ballgames from his perch in the bullpen. Personally, Iíd like to see AA hitting coach Rudy Hernandez considered for one of the openings. Iíve heard that players coming through New Britain speak very highly of Hernandez. Promoting him to the Twins would allow them to give Brunansky an opportunity to actually manage a year in the minor leagues, which might not be a terrible idea.

    Iíve heard a lot of comments about how it isnít fair that the ďlesser coachesĒ got the boot while Gardenhire, Anderson and even Ullger and Vavra (since theyíll still be with the Twins) survived. Frankly, thatís true. It isnít fair. But this isnít about ďfair.Ē

    Baseball coaches at the professional level all know that their jobs are only as safe as the teamís performance on the field. They work under relatively short term contracts and they all know those contracts are subject to not being renewed for any reason. In this case, the primary reason Stelly, White and Liddle didnít have their contracts renewed was more about Terry Ryanís desire to bring a new group of coaches in to the clubhouse than any real or perceived performance issues on those coachesí parts. I think itís safe to say Jerry White didnít cost the Twins too many games this season. Ryan needed to create three vacancies to create room for his guys, pure and simple.

    Iím fine with these moves, both with the coaching changes and with retaining Gardenhire and Anderson, for now. But my being fine with them is conditioned on these moves not being the last bold moves Ryan makes this offseason. In fact, if March rolls around and the coaching changes are considered to be even close to the biggest moves heís made, Iíll be well beyond just very disappointed.

    Mr. Ryan, you have gotten our attention. Now show us what you do for an encoreÖ and it had better be good.

    - JC
    This article was originally published in blog: Ch-Ch-Ch-Changes started by Jim Crikket
    Comments 7 Comments
    1. JB_Iowa's Avatar
      JB_Iowa -
      First, I don't consider the coaching changes to be particularly bold. I've felt -- and said -- for some time that they needed to be "bleeding in" new talent in the coaching ranks. And it's just now occurring to them that they need a Spanish-speaking coach? There have been cries for that around for a number of years. I consider the moves they made to be too little, too late. A couple of scapegoats and very little real change. (Yes, that may change next season but all they are doing is prolonging the bleeding).

      2. Why is it that we haven't seen any front office changes except McWane? Bill Smith did not make his decisions in a vacuum. In fact, he probably relied on the opinions and evaluations of his subordinates much more than Terry Ryan does. The lack of front office turnover leads me to see the coaching staff as scapegoats for the failure of this organization. (Not that the coaching staff is blameless but WHY hasn't anyone other than Bill Smith been called to account for what they had to work with -- oh, and surprise me but Bill Smith still has a job with the club whereas Stelmazek and Jerry White don't).

      3. Players -- I assume one of the bold moves you are looking for is spending some bucks on the free agent market. They've got the bucks to do so. The other moves would, of course, be trades. I'm not convinced that they know how to make trades anymore (other than piddling around). But yes, I'm looking for some pretty darn BOLD moves in the player arena -- they have to have the WILL (and ability) to make them and I'm not convinced that they do.

      4. I want some evidence that they GET that they weren't all that good even before the last 2 seasons. They were above-average but they were definitely not top 30%.
    1. SpantheMan's Avatar
      SpantheMan -
      I woul say they were top 30%. They were in the playoffs most years, even considered a model organization on how to succeed with a low payroll.
    1. Jim Crikket's Avatar
      Jim Crikket -
      JB, for an organization that's made exactly one minor coaching change in the past decade, making three of them at once is pretty bold. It's all relative, I guess. The need for a Spanish speaking coach has indeed been clear for a long time and you're right, a lot of us have pointed that out frequently. I'd prefer it be someone other than the bullpen coach, but any progress is welcome on that front by the Latin American players, I'm sure. I'm also not real sure what changes have been made in the front office. My suspicion is that, while few if any people outright lost their jobs the way White, et al, have, there's been a bit of a difference in terms of who actually has influence and decision-making authority. Smith's responsibilities appear to be related to things like dealing with minor league affiliate relationships and representing the Twins with regard to renovating their Spring Training site, for example.

      I'd like to see some bold moves on the free agent market, but honestly I don't much care if the moves come from there or from the trade market. If Ryan feels free to trade from organizational strength to fill its weaknesses and can do so, that's actually better than doing it via free agency because there's no commodity more overpriced on the free agent market than top of the rotation starting pitching.

      With 5 out of 15 teams in each league qualifying for the playoffs going forward, being top 33% will get you there. Whether the Twins were actually at that level every year of the decade prior to the past two years or not is certainly debatable. I'm just not that concerned about that debate at this point. I don't expect the Twins to jump from 96 losses to being an elite team in one season. Regardless of how the team got in to the situation it's in now, we need to see progress going forward and some indication that the FO is serious about making that progress.

      I've commented in the past that it's been hard at times to even feel like the front office has noticed that things are as bad as they are. I'm willing to say last week's moves indicate they've noticed. However, the moves made over the coming months will be far more indicative of whether we can believe there's a commitment to doing something about the situation.
    1. diehardtwinsfan's Avatar
      diehardtwinsfan -
      I'm waiting for something to be done with the medical staff. I'm guessing the guy in charge there should be let go, and they should bring in someone from another organization... like Tampa Bay.
    1. Brock Beauchamp's Avatar
      Brock Beauchamp -
      Quote Originally Posted by diehardtwinsfan View Post
      I'm waiting for something to be done with the medical staff. I'm guessing the guy in charge there should be let go, and they should bring in someone from another organization... like Tampa Bay.
      The head trainer was let go.
    1. spideyo's Avatar
      spideyo -
      Remember too, that there are a lot of people in the "front office" and the scouting department, most of whom you've never heard of, and most of whom will not have their employment status announced at a press conference. Just because they haven't announced big changes in the front office, doesn't mean they haven't happened.
    1. diehardtwinsfan's Avatar
      diehardtwinsfan -
      Quote Originally Posted by Brock Beauchamp View Post
      Quote Originally Posted by diehardtwinsfan View Post
      I'm waiting for something to be done with the medical staff. I'm guessing the guy in charge there should be let go, and they should bring in someone from another organization... like Tampa Bay.
      The head trainer was let go.
      Then I am very happy. Not sure the entire staff needed to go, but someone at the top needed to be held accountable.
©2014 TwinsCentric, LLC. All Rights Reserved.
Interested in advertising with Twins Daily? Click here.