Jump to content

Providing independent coverage of the Minnesota Twins.
Subscribe to Twins Daily Email

The Forums

Twins, OAK a good match? Gibson & Odorizzi available

Minnesota Twins Talk Today, 07:04 AM
Some interesting trade news floating around this morning.   -Susan Slusser of the San Francisco Chronicle seems to be connecting the...

Article: 2018 Minnesota Twins Midseason Top Prospect List...

Twins Minor League Talk Today, 06:56 AM
The true tragedy of the 2018 season?How it's tarnishing the hopes of so many Minnesota Twins fans who've earnestly bought into the vision...

Article: Twins Prospect Pulse: Promotions and Short-Seaso...

Twins Minor League Talk Today, 06:45 AM
Welcome to another edition of the Twins Prospect Pulse. Over the past month we’ve seen several big promotions (Alex Kirilloff, Brusdar Gr...

Article: MIN 11, TB 7: Dozier Grand Slam Ends Wild Game,...

Minnesota Twins Talk Today, 06:30 AM
There was an entire season’s worth of moments in just this one game Sunday afternoon at Target Field. A run scored on a balk, there were...

Article: Dozier’s Days Numbered, Then What?

Minnesota Twins Talk Today, 06:10 AM
Despite sweeping the hapless Baltimore Orioles, and then taking a series from the equally terrible Kansas City Royals, the Minnesota Twin...


Grading Out The 2017 Twins: Starting Pitching

Posted by Ted Schwerzler , 10 October 2017 · 783 views

With the Minnesota Twins now finished with both the regular and postseason portions of their 2017 Major League Baseball season, it's fair to look back on the year that was. This group matured, and turned around a catastrophic 2016 effort to once again give steam to a young team going places. It was a group effort, but breaking down individual performances is a must as well.

In order to provide some brevity, we'll make this a three part series. Today, grades will be handed out to the starting pitching. Monday we looked at the offense, and Wednesday will conclude with the relief group. While the Twins got starts from a ridiculous amount of different arms (16), this will focus on the five that turned in the most work.
All of the groundwork is out of the way, let's get into it.

Ervin Santana A

Over the course of the year, there wasn't much more of a steadying presence on the mound than that of Ervin Santana. He started strong out of the gates, and finished well down the stretch. There was a bit of a lull in the middle, but the final numbers resulted in a 3.28 ERA along with a 7.1 K/9 and a 2.6 BB/9.

Santana wasn't flashy, and he's never been as much, but his repertoire allowed for consistent production. For the bulk of the year, his slider had good bite, and he was able to keep opposing hitters at bay. Homers once again were an issue for him, but there's little reason not to feel good about Santana taking the mound for another 30-plus starts with Minnesota in 2018.

Kyle Gibson C+

More than any other starter for the Twins, it was a tale of two seasons for Gibson. He was demoted to Triple-A Rochester, and cast off for Jaime Garcia at one point. Through his first 16 starts of 2017, he owned a terrible 6.31 ERA and was allowing opposing hitters a .934 OPS off of him. After making some tweaks, mid-July began a new narrative. Over his final 13 starts, Gibson owned a 3.76 ERA and allowed just a .701 OPS to opposing hitters.

For years, Twins fans (as well as the front office) have hoped Gibson would round out into the first round selection he was taken as. A sinkerballer with the ability to keep the ball in the yard, the hope was that Gibson would be a ground ball machine that doesn't give up much of anything. That hasn't been the case thus far, but the second half of 2017 provides plenty of reason for excitement. Gibson will be tendered a new deal this offseason, and hoping he can be a rotation fixture in 2018 is a good place to be.

Jose Berrios B+

With Berrios, the Twins saw growth but also the volatility of young arms. Posting a 3.89 ERA on the year, the Puerto Rican native has to feel good about how his season went. With an 8.6 K/9, he flashed the ability to strike out plenty of big league hitters. There were a lot of high points, and only a few clunkers mixed in.

Coming off a tough showing his rookie year, Berrios established himself a a big league difference maker this season. Going into 2018, it's a certainty that he's a lock for the Minnesota rotation, and it will be interesting to watch him push his ceiling. He has flashed true ace ability, and Minnesota desperately needs that trend to continue. Another step forward for Berrios a year from now, could have him entering some end of season award discussions.

Adalberto Mejia C

When acquired from the Giants in exchange for Eduardo Nunez, the Twins had to be thrilled getting a capable big league arm. Mejia had began to appear on top 100 prospect lists, and he looked the part of a back-end big league starter. Across 21 outings this season, a 4.50 ERA was indicative of being virtually who he was billed to be.

Mejia isn't flashy by any means, and while he can strike batters out (7.8 K/9), he also needs to work on limiting free passes (4.0 BB/9). Getting deep in games was a struggle for him this season, and that's going to need to be a focus going into 2018. Pitch economy, as well as command are areas for growth. He'll be fighting among a group of options to round out the rotation a year from now.

Bartolo Colon C-

Although the long time veteran's 5.18 ERA is anything but exciting on paper, it was such a necessary addition for Minnesota. Picked up from Atlanta after a dismal start to the year, Colon provided a leverl of certainty for the Twins. He found a better defense to help him out, and continued to be a command artist in his elder years (1.7 BB/9).

It sounds like Colon wants to pitch again next season at age 45. He's survived this long simply by throwing strikes, and that's something the Twins needed from a fifth guy when he stepped in. I can't imagine a scenario in which he's back with the organization to start next season, but he showed that he still has a little more to give, and he helped the Twins down the stretch. It was rarely pretty, but given what the other 11 guys who made starts for Paul Molitor's squad this year did, it was relatively effective.

For more from Off The Baggy, click here. Follow @tlschwerz

  • howieramone2 likes this

Too high - Santana A, yes, Berrios a B - remove the + he needs to hold it together longer and I think he will next year.Gibson had an F the first half and a C+ the second.That makes a C- for the year.Mejia was a C-, he never really shined.Colon gets a PR A, but I am hoping he is gone he was all over the map and after a fun short ride, until the last game when no one cared he was a D.   

Gibson will be tendered because of the shortage of starting pitching and his finish. Mejia I hope will be better, but the Twins had better expect to fill 2 starting pitching holes if not 3.

Ted Schwerzler
Oct 10 2017 12:02 PM


Gibson will be tendered because of the shortage of starting pitching and his finish. Mejia I hope will be better, but the Twins had better expect to fill 2 starting pitching holes if not 3.


Gibson will and should be tendered. If you want an ace, I'd deal from the prospect pool for one. Otherwise, I'd be all for signing 2 of Lynn, Chatwood, and Cobb.

Gibson might not be a tale of two halves, as Gibson's season as a whole was slightly worse than his career stats (Fangraphs source)


Career ERA 4.70 xFIP 4.21

2017 ERA 5.07 xFIP 4.35

His K rate, BB rate, and Hard Hit rate were all elevated in 2017 over his career.


Rather than two seasons, to me it looks like the second half was just his normal streakiness throughout his career. He is what he is.


Maybe he should be resigned, but he absolutely should be on the 5th starter bubble in spring training. I'd think about non-tendering him and sign him to a lower contract later.

Santana had too many poor outings to be an "A" and his poor clutch performance in the playoffs leave him as a "B" at best.
Berrios earned a rating of "B+"
Gibson was a first half "F" and a second half "B" so let's say "C-"
Mejia was a "C", however that was due to the short leash Molitor had him on and the quick hook when Mejia got into trouble.
Colon was a "C" for the Twins and a "C-" for the year, remember he came off the scrapheap.
And what of the ratings for the other 11 starters used???

How many games did Santana lose or no-decision because of meek offense or a bullpen that couldn't hold the lead.


Berrios is still a work in progress, but has the potential.


Gibson is getting a BIG second chance.


And then there is none.