Jump to content

Providing independent coverage of the Minnesota Twins.
Subscribe to Twins Daily Email

The Forums

Article: Is Paul Molitor the Right Man to Lead the Twins?

Minnesota Twins Talk Today, 07:31 AM
Shortly after they hired Paul Molitor as manager in November of 2014, the Twins invited me to Target Field for a one-on-one interview wit...

Article: Twins Minor League Report (6/21): Thorpedo Locke...

Twins Minor League Talk Today, 07:31 AM
There were too many great performances across the Twins’ minor league system to mention them all in this intro, but Lewis Thorpe was part...

Article: The Gib is Up, Kyle Is For Real

Minnesota Twins Talk Today, 07:26 AM
There’s no need to remind you of what Kyle Gibson was, we’re all aware. Early on in the 2017 season, the former first round pick looked l...

Article: Lance Lynn Was Worth The Wait

Minnesota Twins Talk Today, 07:21 AM
It has been an eventful last few months for Lance Lynn to say the least. It all started back in November, when he became a free agent for...

Article: Let's Talk About Eduardo Escobar

Minnesota Twins Talk Today, 07:05 AM
Eduardo Escobar's day at the park ended shortly after a Rick Porcello fastball bounced off the vulnerable part of the arm just above the...


Twins 25 Man Roster Projection 2.0

Posted by Ted Schwerzler , 16 March 2017 · 2,611 views

With just a couple of weeks left of baseball down in Fort Myers, the Twins are gearing up quickly for the beginning of the 2017 Major League Baseball season. In what should be a much more competitive season, Paul Molitor's club is looking to put their best foot forward. It's been nearly two months since I last looked at the 25 Minnesota will take north two months ago, and an update is more than overdue.

Although there hasn't been a ton of shuffling, the Twins have been dealt a significant injury blow, as well as having played more than a handful of games. Looking at the landscape right now, here's how I see it playing out:

Rotation (5)
  • Ervin Santana
  • Phil Hughes
  • Kyle Gibson
  • Hector Santiago
  • Adalberto Mejia
The only change here is that Trevor May is obviously no longer a candidate. I think he had the inside track, but with a torn UCL, he's definitely out of the picture. The Twins could go Ryan Vogelsong for the final spot, but that'd be settling in the most disappointing way possible. Jose Berrios could also factor in, as he's got a higher upside the Mejia. Thus far though, Mejia has been sharp this spring, gives Minnesota another lefty, and has the staying power to remain in the rotation for the long haul.

Starting Lineup (9)
  • Jason Castro C
  • Joe Mauer 1B
  • Brian Dozier 2B
  • Jorge Polanco SS
  • Miguel Sano 3B
  • Eddie Rosario LF
  • Byron Buxton CF
  • Max Kepler RF
  • ByungHo Park DH
There wasn't ever going to be much change among the starters, they'd been cemented nearly from the get go. The switch here comes in the form of the designated hitter. Initially I had Park pegged, and felt the need to switch things around when he was removed from the 40 man roster. The reality is he's a superior player in comparison to Kennys Vargas, and he's looked as much this spring.

Park is fully healthy with his wrist surgically repaired. He's now more acclimated to the culture of Major League Baseball, as well as undoubtedly feeling more comfortable in a new country. He's looked relaxed at the plate, has chased less, and connected more. Expecting a breakout year from ByungHo is far from a stretch.

Bench (4)
  • Eduardo Escobar
  • Robbie Grossman
  • Ehire Adrianza
  • Chris Gimenez
The only way for Grossman to be unseated would be if the Twins decided they need more of a defensive presence in the outfield off of the bench. In that scenario, Drew Stubbs could get some consideration. Eduardo Escobar and Ehire Adrianza don't pair particularly well, in that they both play the same set of positions, but the former has a bit better bat while the latter plays incredible defense.

Behind the dish, it's become apparent that Chris Gimenez is going to be Jason Castro's backup. He has a level of familiarity with Derek Falvey and Thad Levine having played for both of their previous organizations. He's a strong veteran, and while he may not do anything exceptionally well, he's more than capable as a big leaguer. I'd still bet on Mitch Garver being the next man up however, even ahead of John Ryan Murphy.

Bullpen (7)
  • Brandon Kintzler Closer
  • Ryan Pressly Setup
  • J.T. Chargois
  • Matt Belisle
  • Justin Haley
  • Craig Breslow
  • Taylor Rogers
As it stands in this piece, the pen has seen a pretty significant shakeup from the former roster projection. Kintzler and Pressly remain status quo at the back, but from there, things get interesting. Matt Belisle was brought in on a major league deal and is going to have a role, while I also believe the Twins will keep Rule 5 pick Justin Haley in long relief.

At some point, J.T. Chargois could go from middle relief to high leverage, and it's a role he seems really well suited for. Then the Twins give themselves some real flexibility in having two capable lefties. Craig Breslow has reinvented himself, and looked very strong this spring. Pairing him with the youth of Taylor Rogers could be a great developmental tool as well, and both southpaws can get batters out from both sides of the plate.

We're not too far removed from Spring Training coming to a conclusion, and as we draw ever more near to that point, the Twins will continue to make cuts and provide more clarity. I feel good about this collection of players, and think Minnesota will have an immediate boost in the win column because of them.

For more from Off The Baggy, click here. Follow @tlschwerz

Sadly, Chargois, with all his potential, will probably get bumped to the minors. Man, what a miserable bullpen. Capable guys, but they have to notch it up to be real shut-down guys.


The 5th starter spot is still up for grabs. Sadly, we really wonder who from that lsit will be around in 2018.


Can agree with the lineup AND the bench. Not the best bench. But not sure if I do want to carry Vargas. We don't have a comfortable power replacement for Sano at third if he is the DH. That's where we have some shakiness. Polanco has to make the roster and play and I hope he does well, a well as the outfield...which if they play to their potential will be superstar land.


Of course, we all wonder what Joe Mauer will do in 2017.


I'm so torn between THAT 25-man roster, who filling it with even more rookies. I'm not sure the roster you present will win 70 games. But a roster of prospects might lose 100 again, sadly.

    • jud6312 and Twins Transplant like this
Mar 16 2017 02:06 PM

I think you've got it. I hope – and expect this is the roster they will take north.


I suspect if there are any changes (barring injuries) it would be Haley, Adrianza or Mejia to get swapped out, but I hope not. I think they can all be very good contributors. 


With all due respect to Rosterman, I disagree. I think this team – especially with Mejia, can win 80+ games. 


If I were to take anyone out of your roster, it would be Santiago (hopefully via trade to a NL team) and put in Berrios. I'd give him another shot.

Looks very close.Might swap out Chris Gimenez for Murphy.Only other flaw I see is Molitor likes DanSan so he might make it,but still hoping for DFA. 

Haley might fail in the next 2 weeks, which would give a bullpen spot to Vogelsong or one of the lefties with Rogers moving into the long relief role. 

This was close.

    • Twins Transplant likes this

I'm with Rosterman. With that rotation, bullpen and bench, this team is destined for 70-75 wins.

    • Twins Transplant likes this
Cory Engelhardt
Mar 17 2017 09:39 AM

So they add Park, Giminez and Breslow (not Vogelsong) to the 40 man. We all assume that May and Perkins (probably) could be added to the 60 day dl. Otherwise, who do you have coming off the 40 man? Danny Santana? Michael Tonkin?

    • Twins Transplant likes this
Ted Schwerzler
Mar 17 2017 10:35 AM

So they add Park, Giminez and Breslow (not Vogelsong) to the 40 man. We all assume that May and Perkins (probably) could be added to the 60 day dl. Otherwise, who do you have coming off the 40 man? Danny Santana? Michael Tonkin?

Glad you asked, was the subject of my piece earlier this week: http://offthebaggy.b...erhaul.html?m=1

If they do indeed add 4 of those 5, I'd like to retract my statement about 70-75 wins ... it'll be much, much lower.


Rhino and Compass
Mar 18 2017 12:47 PM

I think we will know what kind of front office the Twins have if Justin Haley breaks camp with the team. He hasn't done much this spring, and there are probably better options, but he was also one of the very few players the new regime added. Will they be OK returninghim? Or even paying to keep him on the roster? Or will they have too much pride and bury him on the roster all year, a la JR Graham? I'm sufficiently intrigued. 

    • Twins Transplant likes this
Twins Transplant
Mar 21 2017 01:01 PM

Watched Edgar Corcino work out and play last week in FM.  We works out in the off season with Jose Berrios in Puerto Rico.  He looks VERY strong and comfortable.  An AMAZING defensive outfielder and SOLID switch hitter.  LOOKING FORWARD to following him on his way to the Twins roster.

Ted Schwerzler
Mar 21 2017 01:58 PM


Watched Edgar Corcino work out and play last week in FM.  We works out in the off season with Jose Berrios in Puerto Rico.  He looks VERY strong and comfortable.  An AMAZING defensive outfielder and SOLID switch hitter.  LOOKING FORWARD to following him on his way to the Twins roster.


Have followed Corcino a good bit as I've developed a decent relationship with Berrios and a couple people he works out with. Corcino is an intriguing guy for sure. He is 24 though and needs to spend the bulk of this season with Rochester if he's going to get looks from Minnesota.

    • Twins Transplant likes this