Jump to content

Providing independent coverage of the Minnesota Twins.
Subscribe to Twins Daily Email

The Forums

Staying the Course

Minnesota Twins Talk Today, 06:07 AM
Many didn't agree with the roster decisions the Twins made. I hoped they would make some different decisions. Without revisiting each dec...

Article: Twins Minor League Report (4/20): Pitching Trio...

Twins Minor League Talk Today, 05:48 AM
Right-handed pitcher Tyler Duffey, left-handed pitcher Pat Dean and right-handed pitcher Felix Jorge each walked away with "Pitcher of th...

New draft thread

Twins Minor League Talk Today, 05:39 AM
The other one was getting long - so maybe time for a new one?   In any event, Klaw tweetedthat Aiken might make his next start, alth...

Should Arcia have been pulled?

Minnesota Twins Talk Today, 05:33 AM
I suppose it's not surprising to state that one of my all time, absolutely favorite movies is Major League. I could just about quote the...

Mauer and The Beard

Minnesota Twins Talk Today, 05:33 AM
I can't believe we haven't gotten to this subject yet. Yeah or nay on the beard? (I like it, FWIW) Is it permanent? Or does it dramatic...


Photo

The 30-And-Under Experiment (Plus Joe And Glen)

Posted by glp_vt , 28 July 2014 · 677 views

The 30-And-Under Experiment (Plus Joe And Glen) It's over, folks. Time to throw in the towel. Again.

As we push past the trade deadline into the final 50-ish games of the season, conventional baseball wisdom would suggest that the younger players should be getting the majority of the plate appearances and innings. I say we throw caution to the wind.

Let's assume, for the sake of argument, that we find new homes for the likes of Willingham, Suzuki, Correia, and even Duensing, and let's also assume, as expected, that Twins Daily is given complete control over the roster for the remainder of the season. What's the worst that could happen if we refuse to give another PA or IP to anyone under the age of 30?

A 30-or-younger active roster might come out looking like the one below. Try to look past the fact that I have 31-year-olds Mauer, Perkins and Nolasco in there. The guys have contracts. We might as well be realistic here.


25-Man Roster
C Josmil Pinto
1B Joe Mauer

2B Brian Dozier
SS Eduardo Escobar
3B Trevor Plouffe
OF Aaron Hicks
CF Byron Buxton
OF Oswaldo Arcia
DH Kennys Vargas

C Eric Fryer
C/OF Chris Herrmann
SS/OF Danny Santana
1B/OF Chris Parmelee

SP Phil Hughes
SP Ricky Nolasco
SP Kyle Gibson
SP Alex Meyer
SP Trevor May

CL Glen Perkins
SU Casey Fien
LHP Caleb Thielbar
RHP Ryan Pressly
RHP Stephen Pryor
RHP Michael Tonkin
LHP Logan Darnell


Frankly, I've yet to find anyone who can convince me that this isn't a good idea, or at very least a replacement-level one. I'll admit that you probably keep Buxton in AA, but you gotta put fans in the seats somehow, right?

Fire away. Santana or Hicks in CF instead of Buxton? Eddie Rosario in the mix? Go all-in and throw in Jose Berrios? Go for it. It's your organization. TR and Gardy are just working in it.





Photo
PeanutsFromHeaven
Jul 29 2014 05:52 AM

I'm increasingly hoping that this is exactly what happens, (though with Buxton getting more development time in AA), so I'm not much of a critic, would be interested to hear the counter argument though.

  • Report
Photo
John Bonnes
Jul 29 2014 06:32 AM

I'll say this: it would be interesting to see what would happen if the Twins just promoted a bunch of talent, ready or not, and had them work things out at the major league level. I worry it might be a complete disaster, truly a five-lane wide car accident, but it worked in the late 90s - several years later. 

    • beckmt likes this
  • Report

See, if nothing else, I have to think it would be an entertaining disaster. The alternative is equally disastrous, but boring at the same time. And that's the recipe for just god-awful ticket sales next year.

    • Brad Swanson likes this
  • Report