Jump to content

Providing independent coverage of the Minnesota Twins.
Subscribe to Twins Daily Email

The Forums

Watch the Live Play-by-Play of the Virtual Twins Playoffs

Minnesota Twins Talk Today, 10:33 AM
With the real Twins around the corner, I have elected to sim to the playoffs to try and tease how the real club will do this fall, and as...

2020 Game Thread Intros

Minnesota Twins Talk Today, 09:09 AM
Yes, I believe there will be baseball! Further, the Twins would be a popular pick this year to advance to the playoffs and maybe, just ma...

Charley Walters: Twins-Saints partnership talks quietly o...

Twins Minor League Talk Today, 07:30 AM
Very interesting article in Pioneer Press from Charlie Walters. https://www.twinciti...uietly-ongoing/ There’s been a few suggestions in...

Brian Dozier released

Other Baseball Yesterday, 11:29 PM
I noticed this one-sentence item in the most obscure part of this morning's StarTribune print edition:   San Diego released former T...

“Joe Cambria: Saint or Scoundrel? The Controversial Life...

Minnesota Twins Talk Today, 12:07 AM
A couple of weeks ago I mentioned in another thread an upcoming talk, as part of SABR's 2020 virtual convention, concerning the old Senat...

Photo

Minnesota Twins: 5 reasons for caution (the hay isn't in the barn yet)

Posted by billyp4444 , 23 February 2020 · 4,658 views

Minnesota Twins: 5 reasons for caution (the hay isn't in the barn yet) 1) The infield defense is slightly suspect and below average. -Sano, Arraez and Polanco all have below average defensive stats
2) Jake Odorizzi and Jose Berrios prove to be below average front line starters. Yes they've proven themselves as #3's. Can they repeatably beat other teams 1's and 2's?
3) Byron Buxton is delayed and/or hurt again
4) Mitch Garver and the rest of the offense return to normal temperature instead of red hot
5) Injuries- This applies to any team but 5 starters (Sano, Cruz, Buxton, Donaldson and Kepler) have all battled the injury bug in recent years. Not too mention 5 of the 7 starting pitchers (Odorizzi, Bailey, Maeda, Hill, Pineda)

All this said the Twins should be a contender, I'm just saying the hay isn't in the barn yet.....

  • nclahammer and jud6312 like this



My Uncle Don always told us he would never feed those round bales to his cattle. He preferred that his livestock have a square meal.That being said, it's exciting to have the boys back, and hard not to be optomistic.

    • jjswol and Oldgoat_MN like this

Berrios: 14-8 with a 3.60 ERA and 200 strikeouts. All-Star.

 

Odorizzi: 15-7 with a 3.51 ERA and 180 strikeouts. All-Star.

 

Both of those lines would be clear frontline ace numbers for at least 70% of the teams in the league.

 

Remember Zack Wheeler, that pitcher we talked about all winter? The "ace" we needed to add? His stats: 11-8, 3.96 ERA, 200 strikeouts. Berrios won more games, pitched more innings, and had a better ERA than him.

 

Remember when the Twins used to go into the year with guys like Kevin Correia as their #1 starter? Gee whiz. I know it doesn't hurt to hope for improvement, but let's give Berrios and Odo a little credit here.

Photo
twinsfanstreif
Feb 24 2020 07:49 AM

I'll counter point these:

1) we added Josh Donaldson to this infield defense and that should trickle down meaning that Polonco should be better with a better 3B next to him and Sano's metrics should improve at 1B.

 

2) this narrative is simply wrong. Both players placed in the top 30 MLB pitchers in bWAR and fWAR. Both also placed among the top 10 AL starting pitchers in both metrics. Sure neither are Cole or Verlander but they are hardly "#3s"

 

3) Nothing in that article you posted states that he's hurt or delayed, it's mostly positive on his recovery

 

4) as for Garver he may come back to earth a bit however he was very good in the minors and he credited his 2019 break out to a change in swing. This kind of thing can happen to players and there's plenty of evidence for sustainability with changes in swing or approach. As for the rest of the offense it's not like anyone other than Garver were experiencing way above their average output. Cruz was a bit higher but he's always been a great player. Adding someone like Donaldson and having Sano healthy for a whole year could do a whole lot. Honestly even if there's some regression we will still have a top 5-10 offense, that's just how good this group is.

 

5) Injuries happen, literally every player outside of Cal Ripken Jr has experienced injuries and every team in history has had to deal with them, this is nothing new. This is also the first year in a long time that I feel like we have the depth practically across the board to deal with injuries anywhere. This part doesn't concern me outside of a freak string of injuries at every position. We'll be good

Photo
twinsfanstreif
Feb 24 2020 08:03 AM

 

Berrios: 14-8 with a 3.60 ERA and 200 strikeouts. All-Star.

 

Odorizzi: 15-7 with a 3.51 ERA and 180 strikeouts. All-Star.

 

Both of those lines would be clear frontline ace numbers for at least 70% of the teams in the league.

 

Remember Zack Wheeler, that pitcher we talked about all winter? The "ace" we needed to add? His stats: 11-8, 3.96 ERA, 200 strikeouts. Berrios won more games, pitched more innings, and had a better ERA than him.

 

Remember when the Twins used to go into the year with guys like Kevin Correia as their #1 starter? Gee whiz. I know it doesn't hurt to hope for improvement, but let's give Berrios and Odo a little credit here.

Yeah, Berrios and Odorizzi also have a very similar WAR to Wheeler as well and they both had better WARs than Syndergaard no matter how you calculate the metric

    • Doctor Gast likes this
Photo
stringer bell
Feb 24 2020 08:37 AM

I'll put it this way--how many players had their best season last year? For sure, Garver, Kepler, Berríos, Odorizzi, Polanco, May, Duffey and Rogers. Can we expect a number of these mostly young veterans to continue to get better? I don't think so, as a matter of fact, it might be a career year for a number of those guys. Among the players who were here last year,there aren't many who we can expect to be measurably better and there are a number of regression candidates.

 

I think the Twins will continue to be good because they brought in more talent. They have a deep starting rotation, deep bullpen and a very good starting lineup. I doubt they'll win 100 again, but I think they should be favorites to win the division and perhaps get deeper into October. Nothing is guaranteed. They need to play with a chip on their shoulders.

    • jud6312 likes this
Photo
Doctor Gast
Feb 24 2020 09:48 AM

Berrios & Odorizzi are the bright spots of our rotation! We expect a very good year from both of them

Photo
woolywoolhouse
Feb 24 2020 10:01 AM

6) The ball. We saw in the playoffs what the Twins offense did with a different ball than what was used in the 2019 regular season. A lot of hits that would have been homeruns in the regular season were caught on the track by the Yankees (and two I can remember specifically in Game 3 by Judge in right.) Yes, every team hit the same ball last season, and the Twins hit it amongst the best. Twins hitters will have to contend with not just hitting "bombas" in 2020 to score their runs if the ball goes back to the less-aerodynamic version pre-2019.

    • DannySD likes this

 

I'll counter point these:

1) we added Josh Donaldson to this infield defense and that should trickle down meaning that Polonco should be better with a better 3B next to him and Sano's metrics should improve at 1B.

 

2) this narrative is simply wrong. Both players placed in the top 30 MLB pitchers in bWAR and fWAR. Both also placed among the top 10 AL starting pitchers in both metrics. Sure neither are Cole or Verlander but they are hardly "#3s"

 

3) Nothing in that article you posted states that he's hurt or delayed, it's mostly positive on his recovery

 

4) as for Garver he may come back to earth a bit however he was very good in the minors and he credited his 2019 break out to a change in swing. This kind of thing can happen to players and there's plenty of evidence for sustainability with changes in swing or approach. As for the rest of the offense it's not like anyone other than Garver were experiencing way above their average output. Cruz was a bit higher but he's always been a great player. Adding someone like Donaldson and having Sano healthy for a whole year could do a whole lot. Honestly even if there's some regression we will still have a top 5-10 offense, that's just how good this group is.

 

5) Injuries happen, literally every player outside of Cal Ripken Jr has experienced injuries and every team in history has had to deal with them, this is nothing new. This is also the first year in a long time that I feel like we have the depth practically across the board to deal with injuries anywhere. This part doesn't concern me outside of a freak string of injuries at every position. We'll be good

 

I like your optimism, let's see how all this plays out. If everyone plays true to past numbers than yes, "put the hay in the barn".

 

However the article is titled reasons for caution, not doomed for failure. I hope I'm wrong on all of these

On Gleeman and the Geek's Sunday podcast, they talked about who was the hardest to replace if injured of positionplayers. I would agree with them that Buxton, Garver, and Polanco are the hardest to replace. CF has big dropoff when Buxton not playing, Kepler serviceable but then weaker in CF and RF. Who is the next true CF in system, Lewis, Celestino? We have C prospects, but rely on Astudillo until they are ready? Who is next SS, Lewis, Gordon? Who is next after Lewis? I like Adrianza but maybe not everyday player. There are some negative injury scenarios, hopefully they don't happen

Photo
tarheeltwinsfan
Feb 25 2020 03:26 PM

This reminds me of a story in my picture book when I was a little boy. It was about a lady who was afraid to walk down the basement stairs because an axe was hanging beside the stairs on the wall. She was worried "What if the axe falls." Injuries happen. For the most part they are unpredictable. One of the many things I like about this Twins organization is that there are capable replacements at every position.

5 reasons will be the following

1. starting pitching

2. starting pitching

3. starting pitching

4. starting pitching

5. defense