Jump to content

Providing independent coverage of the Minnesota Twins.
Subscribe to Twins Daily Email

The Forums

Free Agency / Re-Signings 2020-21 Offseason

Other Baseball Today, 05:42 PM
Free agency is likely going to be a really slow burn this year, but I still think it's worth having a thread to discuss signings. ...

How to value last year, alternate site players

Minnesota Twins Talk Today, 04:51 PM
In attempt to change subject from free agent signings, how will the teams value the time players spent at alternate sites last year. Most...

Twins struggle with free agency

Minnesota Twins Talk Today, 04:49 PM
What's going on with Twins struggle to sign anyonesignificant in free agency? Do players not want to come to Twins team? Last year Twins...

Adrianza signing elsewhere?

Minnesota Twins Talk Today, 04:48 PM
Ehire Adrianza posted a Thank You message to the Twins and their fans on his Instagram page earlier today. Can't find any reports yet on...

Twins Top Prospects - FanGraphs

Twins Minor League Talk Today, 03:04 PM
I haven't seen any notice on Twins Daily yet, so thought I'd leave this here.   Eric Longenhagen has posted his new Twins prospect l...


Projecting Minnesota's Optimal Defensive Line-Up

Posted by Cody Christie , in Minor Leagues 04 February 2016 · 2,221 views

byron buxton max kepler eddie rosario stuart turner engelb vielma
Defense wins championships.

In the baseball world, this cliche might not be completely true. Otherwise, there would be teams full of Andrelton Simmons-type players. There are a lot of other factors that go into the overall equation. Teams need offense, they need pitching, and sometimes a little luck goes a long way.

Baseball line-ups aren't usually built with a defensive as the first priority. Rosters usually need to have the right combination of defense and offense. You can hide a Josh Willingham-type player in a corner outfield spot if he is mashing a bunch of home runs.

What would the Twins line-up look like if it was made up completely with defense as the only factor in making roster decisions?
Posted Image
Outfield: Byron Buxton, Eddie Rosario, Max Kepler
In this line-up, there are no converted infielders pushed to a corner outfield spot. This team is all about speed, range, and having a cannon for an arm. Luckily for the Twins, their optimal defensive line-up is one that could see some significant playing time this season. All three players have seen time in centerfield during their minor league careers. Buxton was just named the best defensive player in the minors by MLB.com and Rosario finished second in the AL with 16 outfield assists. Add Kepler to the mix and you have one strong trio that would be able to cover foul pole to foul pole with ease.

Catcher: Stuart Turner
Kurt Suzuki has taken a beating behind the plate over the last couple seasons and he has his flaws as a defensive catcher. The Twins traded Aaron Hicks to the Yankees for catcher John Ryan Murphy this offseason and his defense is fine for now. Two players, Stuart Turner and Mitch Garver, are the future of the position are in the Twins system. Turner is the better defensive option and he could probably hold his own at the big league level behind the plate. He could be up as early as this September as he should spend a good chunk of the year in Rochester.

First Base: Joe Mauer
Ever since his high school days, Mauer has been considered a good athlete. That's why there was little concern over him making the defensive transition from catcher to first base. Everything hasn't been perfect for Mauer in the move to a corner infield spot but he continues to learn the nuisances of what has become his new home. Mauer's former roommate, Justin Morneau, was a very strong defensive first baseman. While Mauer might not be to that level yet, he is still a strong defensive option.

Second Base: Jorge Polanco
Brian Dozier's defense has been on a steady decline over the last three years which makes it a little easier to look past him when creating the team's best defensive line-up. Another prospect with a lot of time at shortstop could be a better solution in the middle infield. Jorge Polanco, like Dozier, would need to shift from shortstop to second base. There have been plenty of questions about whether or not he will be able to stick at shortstop. This solves the problem by moving him off the position and possibly offers a little up-side over Dozier and his declining defense. A younger, more athletic player seems like a better option over an aging Dozier.

Third Base: Trevor Plouffe
It's hard not to be impressed with how far Trevor Plouffe has come at the third base position. As he transitioned to third from shortstop and a brief taste of the outfield, he looked stiff and unable to adjust to the fast pace of being at the "hot corner." By the end of this season, he ranked as one of the best defensive third basemen in the American League according to the SABR Defensive Index. Miguel Sano might take over this position in the near future but Plouffe's defense will be hard to top.

Shortstop: Engelb Vielma
Unfortunately (or fortunately depending on how you look at it), the Twins best defensive option at shortstop hasn't played a game above the High-A level. Many of the top national prospect rankings peg him as the best defensive infielder in the organization with quite possibly the best infield arm. His offense might be a couple years away from being big league ready but his defense is ready to make the next step.

Now it's your turn. Who would be in your defensive line-up? Leave a COMMENT and join the discussion.

I have never saw Vielma play. But all I hear about him is he can pick it. I also hear he can't hit, but his numbers at A ball aren't that terrible it seems. Given a choice I always want a elite fielding SS and CF over an offensive one. It makes your pitchers better, and allows you to hide that corner OF power guy. As for Polanco, I was surprised at the choice. His knock has been poor defense. That's not saying he could not replace Dozier, who I think gets style points on defense which camouflage his deficiencies. And his offense is at a crucial stage. He is either going to have to start going the other way, and give up trying to hit 30 HR's or he will end up the second half version of BD all year. I look for him to be the offensive disappointment of the year for the Twins.
Cory Engelhardt
Feb 05 2016 07:59 AM

So do you have Sano as your most talented defensive DH? Or who is to say he wouldn't be the best fielding 1st baseman on the roster? :)

That said, I like the idea of Polanco at 2nd. I don't know what that means for Dozier.

Feb 05 2016 03:47 PM

I like the list - probably accurate. Except for 2B – I'd pick Dozier. Polanco hasn't had enough reps at 2B yet for me to pick him.

Also – what about pitcher? Who's the best defensive pitcher in the Twins' organization?