Jump to content

Providing independent coverage of the Minnesota Twins.
Subscribe to Twins Daily Email

The Forums

Front Page: Twins Game Recap (8/23): Berríos, Bullpen Can...

Minnesota Twins Talk Today, 12:31 PM
Kicking off the Players Weekend, the Twins hosted the first of a three-game series against the team with the worst record and offense in...

Game Thread "David" Twins vs. Tigers 6:10pm edt 8...

Minnesota Twins Talk Today, 12:26 PM
Top 10 rejected game thread intro ideas: 10. Pig latin. 9. Rip Van Winkle 8. The Good, the Bad, and the Ugly. 7. Thesis abstract. 6. Prop...

Front Page: Getting Defensive

Minnesota Twins Talk Today, 12:19 PM
Remember when Doug Mientkiewicz was really good at first base for the Twins one year, but Rafael Palmiero won the Gold Glove despite bare...

Front Page: Twins Minor League Report (8/23): Jhoan Duran...

Twins Minor League Talk Today, 12:04 PM
Jhoan Duran was having a tough first taste of Double-A action, but everything seemed to click tonight. Duran carried a no-hitter into the...

Where are they now? Ex-Twins in 2019

Minnesota Twins Talk Today, 10:18 AM
I had fun with the "Ex-Twins in the Box Scores" post last year. I know, it's too early for any games at this point in the year, but I hav...

Photo

Playoff pitchers - where do Twins rank

Posted by mikelink45 , 12 August 2019 · 723 views

world series playoff twins houston astros ny yankees
Playoff pitchers - where do Twins rank If the playoffs started today – these are the teams and their top three-man rotations. Which would you choose? I have them listed as I would rank them.


Starting three for the playoffs
1. Houston – Verlander, Cole, Greinke
2. Cleveland – Bieber, Clevinger, Kluber
3. Tampa – Morton, Chirinos, Glasnow or Snell if he returns
4. Yankees – Tanaka, Paxton, German or Happ
5. Twins – Berrios, Pineda, Odorizzi

Houston has Aaron Sanchez and Wade Miley, Cleveland has the two rookie pitchers we just saw, Yankees have CC Sabathis, Tampa will make something up, and the Twins have Gibson in reserve.

NL –
1. Dodgers - Ryu, Beuhler, Kershaw
2. Nationals – Strasburg, Scherzer, Corbin
3. Braves – Teheran, Soroka, Fried
4. Cubs – Lester, Hendricks, Quintana
5. Cardinals – Mikolas, Wainwright, Flaherty


The Cardinals have Wacha and Hudson in reserve, the cubs have Yu Darvish (on Boy) and are we glad we lost that signing battle, the Nationals have Annibal Sanchez, and the Braves hope Dallas Kuechel will be dealing by then.

Pick your poison.

The Twins rotation might be as good as the Yankees and Cardinals, but beyond that it is a guess and the Bullpen is the next question. Chapman or Rogers? This keeps the Yankees above us. Not that Rogers and Romo are not doing well, but I think Rogers is wearing out and who do you trust in a tight game against a really good lineup after them?


Bullpen:
AL
1. Yankees – Chapman and Ottavino
2. Houston – Osuna and Pressley
3. Cleveland - Hand and Perez
4. Twins – Rogers and Romo
5. Tampa – Pagan and Roe

NL
1. Dodgers – Jansen and Baez
2. Washington – Doolittle and Suero
3. St Louis – Hicks and Miller
4. Braves – Jackson and Swarzak
5. Cubs – Strop and Kintzler


Yankees ahead by a large margin in BP, then Houston with Dodgers and Cleveland equal and the rest are hard to rate. What is interesting is that three former Twins are in these BP pairs (not counting our own two).
That is it. Houston is my pick at this point based on pitchers and the Nationals and Dodgers tied for NL side.

  • Oldgoat_MN likes this



The secret is your starters going deep into the game. No five innings stints (which is what I worry about with Pineda, Perez and especially Odorizzi). Gibson can shine. Berrios is pretty consistent if he can stay aheda in his counts.

 

But getting six innings out of your starter, and maybe even 7 (if they can refuse to walk people) is the key.

 

Nezt, the Twins bullpen. I have more faith than many in Trevor May. I like Zach Littell. It would be nice to have another lefty. Could that be Perez, Smeltzer, Ryan O'Rourke, Lewis Thorpe. If we had three lefties in the pen...wow! Duffey is doing well, along with Littell, and Ryne Harper is holding his own. Romo is a godsend. Dyson should be back. So the Twins pen looks pretty good. The joy would be to have TWO pitchers that can do long relief, like two innings, if the start is short.

 

I do like that the Twins have taken a look at so many "future" pitchers: Dobnak, Stashak, Poppen, Stewart, Eades, Romero. Hildenberger could still be in the mix. The Twins have unknowns Diplan and Gonsalves on the 40-man. Ryan O'Rourke was an intriguing pickup.

 

But a pen of Rogers as closer, Dyson and Romo as setup, Littell and May as long guys, Harper and Duffey in the mix. Perez could be in the pen if the Twins do decide to stretch out a rookie as the fifth starter (which I would do, especially in September).

 

But for now, the Twins are in a post-season drive. They have to stay ahead of the Indians, or if they slip, ahead of everyone wanting a wildcard spot!

    • brvama and mikelink45 like this

 

The secret is your starters going deep into the game. No five innings stints (which is what I worry about with Pineda, Perez and especially Odorizzi). Gibson can shine. Berrios is pretty consistent if he can stay aheda in his counts.

 

But getting six innings out of your starter, and maybe even 7 (if they can refuse to walk people) is the key.

 

Nezt, the Twins bullpen. I have more faith than many in Trevor May. I like Zach Littell. It would be nice to have another lefty. Could that be Perez, Smeltzer, Ryan O'Rourke, Lewis Thorpe. If we had three lefties in the pen...wow! Duffey is doing well, along with Littell, and Ryne Harper is holding his own. Romo is a godsend. Dyson should be back. So the Twins pen looks pretty good. The joy would be to have TWO pitchers that can do long relief, like two innings, if the start is short.

 

I do like that the Twins have taken a look at so many "future" pitchers: Dobnak, Stashak, Poppen, Stewart, Eades, Romero. Hildenberger could still be in the mix. The Twins have unknowns Diplan and Gonsalves on the 40-man. Ryan O'Rourke was an intriguing pickup.

 

But a pen of Rogers as closer, Dyson and Romo as setup, Littell and May as long guys, Harper and Duffey in the mix. Perez could be in the pen if the Twins do decide to stretch out a rookie as the fifth starter (which I would do, especially in September).

 

But for now, the Twins are in a post-season drive. They have to stay ahead of the Indians, or if they slip, ahead of everyone wanting a wildcard spot!

I agree, but how does our rotation and pen match the others?We did not match well with Cleveland this past series.

 

    • Oldgoat_MN and Aerodeliria like this
Photo
Aerodeliria
Aug 13 2019 10:47 PM

I agree 100% with your starter rankings and I would switch Houston and the NY for relief pitching. We'll have to see how Kluber performs, but I'd say Cleveland was the biggest winner in trading away Bauer. He was getting to be a problem and they've improved their hitting prowess dramatically.

 

I actually give the Twins kudos for getting two relief pitchers in Dyson and Romo. If Dyson can pitch like he did tonight, the Twins bullpen improves dramatically. We all know that overusing Rogers is a lose-lose situation as we experienced in the final game against the Indians.

    • mikelink45 likes this