Twins Extension Candidate: Michael Pineda
Nov 25 2020 09:30 PM |
Cody Christie
in Minnesota Twins
Image courtesy of © Jayne Kamin-Oncea-USA TODAY Sports
Michael Pineda2020 Stats (5 games): 3.38 ERA, 1.20 WHIP, 130 ERA+, 2.22 FIP, 0.4 WAR
Current Contract (Signed thru 2021, 2 years/$20 million)
Michael Pineda’s time in Minnesota has certainly been turbulent. He was recovering from Tommy John surgery when the team signed him so that cost him a season and then he was suspended for using a diuretic. Still, he will only be 32-years old next season and the Twins need pitching depth moving forward. He seems like the most natural person to extend a contract to this winter.
Pros of Extending Now
Few know what the free agent market will look like this winter and there is even less certainty about next off-season. Minnesota has a certain comfort level with Pineda after negotiating two different contracts. Pineda is never going to be a front-line starter, but he provides tremendous value as a middle of the rotation arm with up-side. The Twins could work through an extension now to add some certainty to the rotation moving forward. Especially with Jose Berrios only having two years left of team control.
Cons of Extending Now
Pineda will be 32 for the entire 2021 campaign and he has already missed multiple professional seasons due to arm issues. The Twins could wait out this season, judge his performance, and decide about his long-term future. This would allow multiple teams to be in on the bidding process, but Minnesota would know him better than other teams and be able to make a smart financial decision. He has only pitched part of two seasons in a Twins uniform so there certainly can be some question marks about his performance moving forward.
Possible Extension
There seem to be a couple different routes for the Twins to pursue when it comes to Pineda and a lot comes down to what the player and his agent view as his value. It seems natural for the Twins to want to continue their current contract situation with Pineda being offered 2-year, $20 million deals ever other off-season. However, he might want to cash in with a bigger payday that pushes him out of the Twins financial picture.
How much would you give Pineda in an extension? Leave a COMMENT and start the discussion.
MORE FROM TWINS DAILY
— Latest Twins coverage from our writers
— Recent Twins discussion in our forums
— Follow Twins Daily via Twitter, Facebook or email
9 Comments
I’m a big Pineda fan. Thought it was a great deal when they signed him to two years coming back from TJS and another two years last off-season.
In my mind, he was a 170-inning pitcher in 2019, given that he missed four starts at year end. Very small sample this year, but he was definitely effective.
So if 2020 and 2021 were at $10M each, would he go for another $10M in 2022, with a $10M option for 2023, with perhaps a $2M buyout? That guarantees him an additional $12M for the extra year.
I don't think we saw enough of Pineda in 2020 to justify another deal with him. I'd rather wait to see how he pitches the 2021 season and go from there.
I like Big Mike.Not sure how much of a commitment beyond 2021 is feasible though.I'd think if they can get him to agree to a reasonable dollar amount, the FO will jump.With reduced revenue, I'm not sure what "reasonable" looks like.Fortunately, guys like Falvey and Levine are FAR smarter about this than I am.At some point, club is going to have to figure out what it has in guys like Duran, Balezovic, Chalmers, etc..
The last four years he has won 6,8,11,2 games - I would not call that dependable.Suspensions and injuries.What are we paying for?Would I extend him - yes for no more than two years and for a very team friendly contract - he owes the team more than they owe him.
By the way I know people don't like wins anymore, but a starting pitcher should still reach double figures with some regularity.
Would guess he would want at least 2 years... so 3 year deal... at 12 mil per. With the third year being a team option. Or .... just let this play out... trade him at the trade deadline and bring up his replacement.... one of our young studs.... His call. Take it or we move on...