Jump to content

Providing independent coverage of the Minnesota Twins.
Subscribe to Twins Daily Email

The Forums

Twins remove Calvin Griffith statue

Minnesota Twins Talk Today, 03:03 AM
because TEAR EVERYTHING DOWN!
Full topic ›

Cleveland MLB team reportedly considering name change

Other Baseball Today, 01:16 AM
This is an AP article I lifted from the StarTribune web site.   https://www.startrib...sure/571623572/
Full topic ›

Virtual Twins Baseball Megathread

Minnesota Twins Talk Yesterday, 04:03 PM
Moving forward this will house every game-thread in the comments below until real baseball hopefully comes back. I should have done this...
Full topic ›

Neal: Twins Radio Broadcast Team Will Not Travel

Minnesota Twins Talk Today, 04:52 AM
https://www.startrib...ason/571529672/   LaVelle Neal also wrote that the Twins radio broadcast crew (including Cory Provus and Dan...
Full topic ›

Take Landis Name off the MVP Award

Other Baseball Yesterday, 02:40 PM
Barry Larkin, former MVP, has been calling for removing the Kenesaw Mountain Landis name from MVP awards.Personally, until I read the art...
Full topic ›

Recent Blogs


Recapping the Twins All-Time Best Defender Bracket

Baseball defense has been a tough thing to quantify throughout baseball history. As technology has improved, it has become easier to rate defenders on their jump to the ball, their route to the ball and the overall difficulty of the catch. Not so very long ago, Gold Gloves were awarded for the best offensive player at the position with little to no consideration for their defensive value. Thankfully, the times have changed, and those changes might have impacted the Twins All-Time Best Defender Bracket.
Image courtesy of © Jesse Johnson-USA TODAY Sports
Torii Hunter Region
Hunter’s defensive prowess was something that followed him through his big-league career, even after he was forced to move to a corner outfield position. He won seven Gold Gloves during his time in Minnesota and added two more after signing with the Angels. He was a clear pick as the number one overall seed, but would he have enough to make it through the entire bracket?

Zoilo Versalles might have provided the biggest challenge to Hunter in the region. The former MVP won multiple Gold Gloves at shortstop. Many reached out on Twitter and wondered how many current fans even remembered Versalles and his slick glove up the middle. Even if he was good for his time, Hunter ended up winning the region and moved on to the Final Four.
Attached Image: Slide1.JPG
Kirby Puckett Region
Kirby Puckett made arguably the most famous catch in team history during Game 6 of the 1991 World Series. He wasn’t a one-catch wonder though as he accumulated six Gold Gloves throughout his Hall of Fame career. Unfortunately for Puckett, his region had a strong number two seed and an upset looked like it could be on the horizon.

First, Puckett had to get by Corey Koskie, one of the team’s best defensive third basemen. From there he matched up in the regional final against Joe Mauer, who had defeated Denard Span in round one. Mauer won multiple Gold Gloves behind the plate and likely should have won one during his time at first. He was a tremendous athlete and his defensive skills beat out Puckett to win the region.
Attached Image: Slide2.JPG
Jim Kaat Region
Younger fans might not be aware, but Jim Kaat lived up to his nickname on the mound as he used cat-like reflexes to pounce on batted balls. He holds the team record for Gold Gloves, and he went on to win 16 for his career. Much like Versalles before him, would a younger crowd on Twitter know enough about Kaat to push him through the region?

Kaat’s region was no breeze as it included some of the biggest names in team history. Tony Oliva, Gary Gaetti, and Greg Gagne had a chance to upset the region’s number one seed. The regional final would be a battle between Gaetti, the team’s outstanding World Series third baseman, and Kaat, the top seed. Cooler heads prevailed and Kaat qualified for the Final Four.
Attached Image: Slide3.JPG
Byron Buxton Region
Recency bias could play a role in making Byron Buxton the number two overall seed in the tournament, but he has made some legendary plays in his big-league career. Unfortunately, his career has been limited because of a variety of injuries. Would fans overlook his injury time and allow him to move out of the region?

Buxton first made quick work of Kent Hrbek, a team legend, but one that played his entire career at first base. The lower part of the bracket pitted two other first basemen as one player took over first base from another in a dramatic trade deadline deal. Buxton faced a Gold Glove winner, Doug Mientkiewicz, in the final, but the first baseman couldn’t pull off the upset and Buxton moved on to face Kaat in the Final Four.
Attached Image: Slide4.JPG
Final Four
Torii Hunter versus Joe Mauer and Jim Kaat versus Byron Buxton comprised the semi-final matchups in the Best Defender Bracket. Mauer had upset the number one seed, Puckett, to qualify for the Final Four, but he wouldn’t have enough steam to take down Spider-Man. Fans are more familiar with Buxton and it was easy for him to take down Kaat, especially since Buxton’s defense has been other-worldly when he has been healthy.

Hunter facing off against Buxton in the final was certainly an intriguing match-up. Hunter has more Gold Gloves and was able to stay healthy and on the field for most of his Twins tenure. Buxton makes spectacular plays but there have been injury concerns. Overall, Buxton is a better defender and the fans picked him over Hunter’s longevity.

Do you agree with the results? Leave a COMMENT and start the discussion.

MORE FROM TWINS DAILY
— Latest Twins coverage from our writers
— Recent Twins discussion in our forums
— Follow Twins Daily via Twitter, Facebook or email


  • Share:
  • submit to reddit
Subscribe to Twins Daily Email

Subscribe to Twins Daily Email

4 Comments

How do you compare pitcher to fielder?Outfielder to infielder?Catcher to anyone?

    • glunn, PDX Twin, bighat and 1 other like this
Photo
theBOMisthebomb
Apr 30 2020 02:23 PM
Buxton is the best defender I have ever seen. Now, his success is obviously in spurts here and there so it depends on your criteria if he should win something like this.
    • dex8425 likes this
Photo
Nine of twelve
Apr 30 2020 04:52 PM

WARNING: NITPICK ALERT

 

Baseball purists prefer to say fielding rather than defense.

 

That said, this is an interesting thing to consider. I don't think the determination of the winner is as important as recognizing some of the best fielders in Twins history. I'm glad you included Jim Kaat.

Overall, I think this is a pretty fair breakdown.

 

I think Hunter vs Mauer is a really interesting conversation; both have been accused of being overrated as defensive players, both played positions that were highly impactful defensively before shifting to positions that are much less impactful. It's a really close call there I think?

 

Kaat was probably as elite as Buxton at his position as a fielder, but I think there's just more impact in CF. It's a fair call.

 

It's interesting how few SS are represented here and how many 1Bs are. (and Vic Power and Don Mincher didn't even make the list)


Similar Articles


by Cody Christie , 08 Jun 2020
Photo


by Cody Christie , 31 May 2020
Photo


by Cody Christie , 30 May 2020
Photo


by Cody Christie , 25 May 2020
Photo


by Ted Schwerzler , 21 May 2020
Photo