Jump to content

Providing independent coverage of the Minnesota Twins.
Subscribe to Twins Daily Email

The Forums

Haley Outrighted, Sent Back to Boston

Minnesota Twins Talk Today, 05:00 PM
Justin Haley has spent most of this season on the Disabled List as the team's Rule 5 pick. However, his 30-day DL stint comes to an end o...
Full topic ›

Article: BREAKING: Twins Acquire Garcia From Braves

Minnesota Twins Talk Today, 04:59 PM
The Minnesota Twins finally got their man.After being on the precipice of a deal with the Atlanta Braves for left-handed starter Jaime Ga...
Full topic ›

Article: Game Thread: Twins @ Dodgers, 7/24@9:10pm CT

Minnesota Twins Talk Today, 04:59 PM
The Dodgers have the best record in baseball and we’ve been looking at these games on the schedule assuming that it has already been deci...
Full topic ›

Royals Acquire Cahill, Two Relievers

Other Baseball Today, 04:53 PM
WIthin an hour of the Twins announcing the acquisition of Jaime Garcia, the Royals announced that they have added three pitchers to their...
Full topic ›

Jaime Garcia Failed Trade Playlist - Ooops

Minnesota Twins Talk Today, 04:16 PM
Let's pour our hearts out through music how we feel about the failed trade....    We can do better Atlanta! Give us another ch...
Full topic ›

2013 Rock Cats MVP: Josmil Pinto

I'll be the first to admit that the bulk of my Rock Cats coverage this season has centered around Miguel Sano. And it's for a reason -- he's the best prospect that has played for New Britain since I have been following the team. People were interested in watching grainy videos of his #PowerBanana shots, and were curious about his defensive progression. Also, he's simply an electric personality. Trust me, you'll experience it firsthand in Minnesota next season. But there was much more to this team than Sano. And in my opinion, Sano wasn't the team's most valuable player, even in the months he was here. That honor belongs to Josmil Pinto.








Posted Image
Rock Cats, Red Wings, and now Twins catcher,
Josmil Pinto


What a 6 months it's been for Josmil Pinto. He started in April as the Rock Cats' everyday catcher, and produced offensively and defensively. In fact, he hit .308/.411/.482. Watching him in person several games, it wasn't just his line drive swing that impressed me. He is a decent catcher with a very good arm. He was promoted on August 1 to AAA Rochester. That alone is a significant accomplishment. But Pinto didn't slow down. He continued to excel as a Red Wing, hitting .314/.333/.486, and is now a member of the Twins. He'll likely see significant playing time behind the dish, I expect, as the Twins would be wise to exercise caution with Joe Mauer.


The Twins gave Pinto at least 2 major votes of confidence: first, giving him 2 in-season promotions; and second -- and just as important -- trading Drew Butera at the deadline. These moves suggest that, between Chris Herrmann and Pinto, the Twins' back-up catching spots are covered.


To be sure, many guys offered great contributions this season in New Britain. Miguel Sano, Danny Santana, Trevor May, Michael Tonkin, Daniel Ortiz, Alex Meyer (pre-injury), and Nate Hanson (he played all over the field very well) all come to mind. But none of these guys was as valuable on both sides of the ball, and was as consistent, as Pinto. He hit over .300, had a good K-to-walk ratio, showed good power and continued to improve on defense. Yes, he still has a ways to go on the defensive front, but it won't stop him from being able to contribute to the Twins this September and next season. And in my opinion, the fact that he left the Rock Cats the last few weeks (give or take) of the season wasn't significant enough for one of the guys previously listed to trump his selection.


Being completely honest, my decision is swayed in part by Joe Mauer's concussion. The concept of "most valuable" is subjective. I happen to see more "value" in places where it's needed. A prospect's value isn't tied solely to his current team so much as it is to the organization as a whole. In the Twins' present situation, we might see more value in prospects at shortstop, third base, starting pitching (ouch) and catcher, especially considering Mauer's advancing age and the recent concussion. In short, Herrmann and Pinto will need to step up. If not in 2014, then in 2015. The fact that Pinto has taken major strides this season, while Herrmann has had, for the most part, a rough go of it, reinforces that Pinto is going to get the shot to prove himself at the major league level.


Congratulations, Josmil Pinto, on one hell of a season.


  • Share:
  • submit to reddit
Subscribe to Twins Daily Email

Subscribe to Twins Daily Email

0 Comments